Bagel Jay's
4498 Main St, 14226-3826 - Amherst
Fast Food
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
Contact Information
📞
Phone:
+1 716-839-2222
🌐 Website:
http://www.bageljays.com/
📍
Address:
4498 Main St, Amherst
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews (8)
The bagels are very fresh (we saw a guy making them in the back) and the sandwiches are very delicious. The veggie cream cheese is very flavorful also. The staff are decent and not overall friendly but not rude either. The prices are a little expensive, a family of four spent $36 on 4 sandwiches and 4 drinks.
Read more
Google
i ordered a blueberry bagel toasted w butter and and poppy seed bagel not toasted w lox spread. I was charged 7.70 and i got a blueberry bagel toasted w butter and lox spread. this is not a great combo. i’m not even going to eat it and i can’t go back bc i will be later for work. do better.
Google
Excellent place. Only reason it did not receive five stars was because the prices have been jacked up considerably in the last year. Rendering else was great!
I'm not blaming them personally (not their fault), but it does take away from the overall experience.
Google
What a letdown. Was up here from NYC and thought maybe this place would have a good bagel. Never got to find out. Waited in line for 20 mins and only 3 people were served. The service was so slow I left. Stay away!
Google
Good location, easy to get in and out of. Service staff was friendly, bagels were delicious, and menu offerings were great too.
Tried the "JayNormous" bagel sandwich. Sandwich tasted great, but tall & cumbersome to weild. Would recommend any of the meats on it (sausage, ham, bacon), but in a more managable size.
Read more
Google
Jayden was amazing. Took great care of me. The food was fresh. When it came time to check out, no on was on the register and Izzy gave me an attitude saying someone will be there. But she continued to stand there and pretend to be busy. Customer service was severely lacking from one employee. But Jayden stepped up!
Read more
Google
If you have food allergies this is not the place for you. Cross contamination is huge. Sadly - as I was really looking forward to having their bagels.
Google
I've been going to Bagel Jay's for years. Although I've not been a fan of the new system, where you order your food and immediately have to pay so you can't see how they are preparing it, (because they make you immediately pay and wait) the food is usually decent.
A few weeks ago I went in and ordered food for 5 people to go, only to find they screwed up 3/5 of the bagel orders when I got home. It happens I get it.
Figured I'd try again today.
My daughter and I went in there this morning to order 5 bagel sandwiches. We happened to be both drinking Starbucks we had just purchased before going to get our family's bagel sandwiches our Sunday morning treat.
Some older guy behind the counter (whom I've never seen there before), went out of his way to shout at us "you can't bring those coffees in here". My response, "really"? Drinking Starbucks while waiting in line to make an $80 order was somehow going to hurt their business? This is a bagel place not a coffee shop.
We left without food and I'm never going back. I guess they can afford to throw away loyal customers' business.
I've never been treated so rudely.
Wish there was another choice for bagel sandwiches in Buffalo, to put Bagel Jay's out of business.
Read more
Google
📊 Compare with Other Restaurants
| Restaurant | Score | Tripadvisor | Reviews | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Panera Bread | 70% | 3.3/5 | 3.5/5 | 961 |
| Kyoto Japanese Restaurant | 85% | 4.3/5 | 4.0/5 | 666 |
| Mi Tierra Restaurant Amherst Mass | 79% | 4.3/5 | 3.5/5 | 522 |
| Jimmy John's Sandwiches | 70% | - | - | 0 |
| The Filling Station | 90% | 4.7/5 | 4.5/5 | 410 |
| Insomnia Cookies | 77% | 4.2/5 | 4.5/5 | 676 |