Just my wife an I. She really wanted steak and crab, and we hadn't been here in a while. So glad we came! We both couldn't stop talking about how good our meal was, and how glad we were that we decided to go here. Joe, our waiter was awesome. Steaks were perfectly done, and the crab had the biggest piece of crab meat I've ever seen. We didn't even use the butter the flavor was so good. We'll be going back very soon. Oh, and the French onion soup was the best ever!
Katie Fellenz Musielak
+5
The staff was great and the food was even better. I will definitely return and will recommend this place to others
Dinner was good. I would have given 5 stars but my porkchops were a little under cooked near the bone. My friend said his steak was delicious and cooked perfect. Next time I'll order steak at the steakhouse!!
Absolutely amazing place to eat! I'm forgetting our servers name, but on 06/20/22 at around 5pm, our server (male) was absolutely perfect. I very rarely get that kind of service these days and he was very polite and on point. Will definitely recommend and can't wait to come back!
We travel to the area every couple years with the fire department and stopping here is always a must. This visit was amazing. We had a very large party with some rowdy guys and the waiter handled us seamlessly. Food was great! Trying to make the reservation was a bit difficult but overall amazing....
Absolutely the best Steakhouse in WNY! The meal was spot on... and a totally enjoyable experience all the way around!
Very solid restaurant for prime rib and steak. Disappointed that since the pandemic, the Salad bar is extra, but I do understand. This place reminds of eating out with my parents when I was younger. Also burger loving son thinks they are great here!
Great place, great atmosphere, greeaaat service, great drinks and great food. One of their specials was a teriyaki crusted salmon which was amazing. I can't speak of their steak personally, but I was told by the 3 others that were with me, it was about perfect, and was cooked beautifully. Overall I think it's completely safe to say that Scotch 'N Sirloin is excellent, and totally worth it.
We had an absolutely amazing meal! Our server was fantastic, was super animated and incredibly helpful! We had stuffed banana peppers, clams Rockefeller, and bacon wrapped scallops for our appetizers. Everything was amazing, but definitely recommend the stuffed banana peppers. For dinner we all had the steak special which was I believe in New York strip with a cheesy garlic sauce on top served with green beans and a side. We got the 20 oz and it was literal heaven. Because we had not already tortured ourselves enough, we got dessert and I got this thing that was like a ice cream cake. The hardest thing I've ever done in my life was getting out of that chair to get to my car. I had the meat sweats all night long and I was so horribly uncomfortable and the massive food baby that I had conceived. Would I do it again? Most certainly! 10 out of 10 would recommend this place! And look for the waiter with the long ponytail. He will definitely make your night better!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Amherst
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes