Since moving to Upstate NY and discovering Four Brothers- I don’t think I’ll ever have to go back the city. My husband is a 35+ year restaurant guy having managed, owned, operated and grown concepts- so he’s really picky! 🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️
Food is always consistent and service top notch. It’s next to a drive in movie theatre so I felt like Sandy from Grease. Can’t wait until it gets warmer out and we can roll in with our top down!
Highly recommended in Pleasant Valley, Dover Plains and Millerton and Amenia- ( the ones I’ve gone to)
Great place for an afternoon outdoor meal as long as you don't mind the bees on flowers and veggies all around you!? Great service and food
Excellent crispy base pie style pizza. Dough was soft and crust was crispy. Great pizza with fresh ingredients.
The lasagna was satisfying and tasty. Didn’t have much meat but the rich cheesy sauce made up for it. The lasagna sheets were somewhat thick.
Overall a nice friendly place for a Friday evening meal. Warm, helpful staff.
The food is really great, we ate at Four Brothers two days in a row. This location has an awesome atmosphere especially for kids with an outdoor seating area, movie theater and kiddie rides. The staff is really great and helped me out after leaving something there -- they went above and beyond to keep it safe and have it returned. Thanks Tom and John and the entire staff!
Been going to Four Brothers since opening over 40 years ago. Never had anything other than great meals. Food is top quality, best pizza & Greek salad anywhere & super friendly staff. Billy runs a superb restaurant. Worth the trip.
Me and my Mom went in on a Sat night around 8:00 on our way home from NY. There were only a couple of other patrons there. You seat yourself, I grabbed a window seat. The waitress came right away with the menus and drink order. We ordered a small veggie pizza. The pizza was yummy. I had to flag down the waitress for a refill of soda and extra napkins, which I should've of had to, as she only had 1 other table. Nice atmosphere, except the fake hanging plants those definitely should be taken down. I noticed they have a small private dining area right as you walk in to the left, and they also have a drive in movie area in mid-winter months. I will definitely be back when in the neighborhood again.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Amenia
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes