Food is amazing!!! Staff is always professional,respectful, polite and attentive. Sandy is such a sweet, kind just an all around wonderful woman. I haven't been there in a while but family went recently and loved it as always. I also worked there 1 summer as a hostess and Sandy was also a phenomenal boss; a pleasure to work for. 🙂
R
Rits M
Google
a year ago
5.0
Super cute little café! I came here on July 4 weekend and the lady in charge was also dressed and red white and blue like me. We had a moment where we admired each other‘s outfits and we were seated immediately. They are pretty accommodating with the menu options, I asked for an addition and they were happy to oblige. The food was well prepared and they have simple solid good American food. They have a huge variety of pancakes and a really cute outdoor seating area for the nice days where you can enjoy the sunshine. We did have a really giant desert to celebrate July 4, it was a banana split Sunday and I highly recommend it it is incredibly delicious. It’s made with corn flakes [the right way!]
I'll be back when in the area
B
Barb Shea
Google
a year ago
5.0
In town from Michigan and had a wonderful lunch at the Post Stop Cafe today. Started with a refreshing cocktail then on to a delicious chicken almond sandwich with waffle fries. Finished off with generous slice of carrot cake. Definitely recommend dining here if in the area, I’ll be back! Very friendly and helpful staff.
W
William Mendel
Google
a year ago
5.0
Great place to eat. French onion soup and Chicken Almond salad on a pita is so good! Their breakfast brunch is wonderful. 100% recommended. Great atmosphere, friendly people
F
Frank Morgano
Google
a year ago
5.0
The service is consistently excellent and the food is really good. I always walk out with a smile. Two big fat thumbs up.
S
Shoshi B
Google
2 years ago
4.0
My mother and I took an impromptu trip out on the Island to find not only a Farmer's Market but this little gem.
It's a great little place. Naturally lit with outside seating.
Lots of solid items on the menu, keto friendly.
It is apparently an historical landmark for Westhampton and I thoroughly enjoyed the atmosphere.
The bathroom was beautiful.
G
G Conrad
Google
2 years ago
5.0
Another East End institution. Hadn't been here for a while, but it was nice to see that the quality of the food was still good and the service was still enthusiastic and friendly. Friday Saturday and Sunday they serve brunch lunch and dinner. Brunch, of course, is the best meal of all anywhere ever, so I left fat and happy. Probably going to close for the season in the next week or two, since it's November 12th as I write this.
D
Donald Duck
Google
2 years ago
5.0
Update. Post-pandemic, The Post Stop is back in business! And don't worry, the food is still delicious, and it's still highly recommended!!....Went there for my wife's birthday. a few years back. What a pleasant West Hampton Beach surprise. Delicious, reasonably priced food, and a warm, gracious staff. They make you feel right at home. Definitely worth the trip!
A
Amy Hawley
Google
2 years ago
5.0
The hostess and staff were gracious and accommodating. My brother and I stopped for lunch earlier today. Our food was delicious. Service was terrific. Everyone made us feel welcome. Would definitely go back!
N
Nancy Savalli
Google
2 years ago
5.0
Fabulous everything! The place is charming, food is fresh and delicious and the restaurant is extremely clean! I can’t say enough good things about this place! EAT HERE!
L
Linda Nussbaum
Google
5 years ago
5.0
Food was excellent! Great selection. Something for every taste. The grilled chicken was done perfectly. The burger came just as ordered, medium rare. The scallop special is done to perfection. The waitstaff are always smilling and attentive. I can't comment on the desert because we always walk down to the Beach Bakery for coffee, desert and to listen to live music.
A
Andrea “urcdnfriend”
Google
5 years ago
5.0
Very quaint restaurant in Westhampton, NY. First time visiting and very impressed. Food was excellent. Everyone so pleasant. Pricing was great. Definitely will be revisiting. They only take cash, cheque or American Express. Glad I had enough cash on me. On bright side ATM is right next door.
A
andrea beatty
Google
5 years ago
5.0
Cute little place for lunch. Average prices for the area, food was very good. Staff was very informative and attentive. Really nice outdoor seating on covered porch. Restaurant only accepts cash or amex for payment.
A
Allison Kosina
Google
6 years ago
5.0
Amazing people and fantastic food. Definitely the place to go when you're looking for a quick beer or to hang out for hours with friends. The owner and staff are family people. Always welcoming 😊
N
Nando Lituma
Google
8 years ago
5.0
Bright and appealing. The Post Stop Cafe transports you to an era when good service was good service!!. Try their Turkey Burger it's like a perfect storm of hype. If i could i will give this place 6* !
R
Randall Wood
Google
11 years ago
4.0
A "sure thing" if you want a pleasant meal in WHB. Great steaks, burgers, seafood, salads, soups, light fare. You can't help but find something you like. The outside tables are great for people watching and the interior is intimate - kind of an "Americana" feel to it. Not fancy or ritzy - you'll be fine in khakis and a polo shirt. Recommended but you may have to wait for a table at rush hour. Get your name on the list early.
