Best BBQ around! Seriously, go for one of their specialty sandwiches rather than just plain brisket or pulled chicken/pork (even though theyre good too!). For dessert, hit up the attached creamery for one of their MONSTER sundaes. LOVE this place.
We got there right when it opened, the outside of the building has an amazing pirate theme mural and it carries over to the inside. Had the brisket sandwidch, Mac and cheese and fries. Was perfectly cooked and had great flavor
š³Damn this BBQ is good! Listen, this place is rated by the Food Network as the best BBQ joint in Indiana. I have NO BEEF with that. What I do know is every dish we ordered was super flavorful and delicious. (See photos captions)
Quoted from āONLY in YOUR STATEā article published by Tori Jane (Febru
I hope you're ready to get your fingers covered in BBQ sauce because you're going to want to use your hands. The delicious meat offerings will spur your prival instincts to eat meat with your bear hands. I opted for the brisket and was not disappointed. It was juicy, tender (surprising for briske
So delicious! My first time was a busy Saturday evening, but that didn't matter one bit. The food was fresh, delicious, and fast! They even had the smoker going outside! Got the souvenir cup and filled it with iced tea - twice - so good!!! The best meat was the smoked sausage in my opinion! The meal
Very nice BBQ joint. Clean, efficient, with friendly employees. Will definitely be back when in the area again. Was going to buy a shirt for my husband, but it wasn't pirate themed, so I passed on it.
The barbecue was delicious but what was over the top for me was their peach cobbler! Will definitely be returning for that dessert alone!
What a great place. The BBQ has always been spot on. I have had brisket, pulled pork, chicken and the ribs. All were cooked perfectly with great flavor. I love the sassafras and watermelon teas. Unique, refreshing, and delicious. The pirate theme is fun and the atmosphere is great. Good luck choosin
Go to BBQ joint in Westfield area. Ordered the Amendment and the Hoffanator. I love the veggies, rice, and brisket in the Amendment. Good smoke flavored brisketand good portion. And the rolls are amazing! Son loves the Hoff and gets it every time weāre in town! Line goes quick and worth the little w
The food is awesome! It's been a couple of years since we've been there,and the place has been redone. It has lots of tables now in place of the old antique shop. The ribs were fall-off-the-bone delicious! Glad we were able to get back!
Meats were excellent, fries crispy, rolls delicious, Mac and cheese really creamy. Just overall an awesome experience. Service was quick too! From the south and this BBQ was delicious!!
Only issue would be the hot BBQ sauce is just not hot at all. Would loved to have had some more heat! Overall an
The aesthetics here are fantastic. So much is on theme! As a first timer, I was caught off guard to learn it's all pirate-themed - so cool! The menu items, the decor, all of it - so cool. I had The Captain. It was good, but the next time we come, I'll try something different. I will say the meat had
Ribs were fall off the bone and smokey. Side served in fall apart paper cups that leaked holding averge coleslaw and baked beans of about 2-3 oz. The only thing on the table are napkins and no handy wipes when done. Get your sauce from community counter were you pour what you want into small plast
Was told to come here by a local friend and was amazed! The atmosphere was fun as the restaurant was packed! But the food still came out super fast and was delicious! We both had the brisket and pork combo with Mac and cheese and coleslaw. It was awesome! The real sleeper was the rolls. They were s
I stopped here with a coworker on a drive back from a business trip. The brisket was amazing, the Mac 'n Cheese was great and the fries perfect. I usually don't go for the high carb options but I wasn't thrilled with the other options. I do wish they had some southern style green beans with ham or b
This is best BBQ in Indy, that I have had, hands down. I get the same thing every time and never dissatisfied. Honestly I have never had a bad meal here.
I just hope the youthful hires donāt bring this place down.
This place has blown up and expanded. Plenty of seating and the line moves pretty q
Icon icon! Look up the menu, Butchers Bill is my favorite. They create everything in house including the ranch dressing. Sweet tea? OHHH YES! Be wise and try something new and out of the box.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes