Carsonie's
6000 Westerville Rd, 43081-4070 - Westerville
Updated on
Italian
Pizza
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
Contact Information
📞
Phone:
+1 614-899-6700
🌐 Website:
http://www.carsonies.com/index.html
📍
Address:
6000 Westerville Rd, Westerville
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
920
Google reviews
I went on a Sunday evening by myself around 7pm. It wasn't too busy and I had excellent service. The waitress was very friendly and I appreciate not feeling rushed at all being a solo diner with a book to just enjoy a nice evening. I had the wedding soup which was hot and tasty, seasoned well and didn't taste too salty. The spaghetti and meatballs were a good portion, meatballs were tender, pasta al dente and I enjoyed the roll. Spumoni was to die for delicious and I can't emphasize enough how much I appreciated that a check wasn't throw down without asking about dessert. I wasn't hurried along, and my waitress was very friendly and responsive. I look forward to going back and trying the stromboli next time and bringing my family. Thank you for a lovely evening :)
Read more
Google
Disappointing service and food, definitely won’t be back. We went for my dad’s birthday, and there were 14 of us. We made reservations way in advance, so it was definitely no surprise. I only ever saw one server, and he was trying his best. He accidentally ordered the wrong meal for me, so he said it was being remade. I didn’t get my sub, no joke, until every single person was finished eating. When the bill came, they charged us full price for everything. When I politely asked if they would be willing to remove just my meal (that I barely ate because, hello, who wants to eat with 13 people watching them). The manager apparently said that the best they could do was half. We’re talking $6. I tipped the kid well; I don’t think it was his fault, but I’ll never go back. I don’t imagine any of those 13 other people (or our couple hundred bucks) will either. So disappointed.
Read more
Google
Chicken stromboli was so good. The waitress was very attentive and took care of everything we asked for. We'll be back to try pizza next time.
Google
Food was really good. Sat at the bar and had an excellent old fashioned. Didn't have a to wait that long for my takeout order
My lasagna was delicious. As was my wife's chicken parm. Also had fried pickles and calamari all delicious
Google
Although we’ve lived in the area for a very long time, this was our first experience with Carsonie’s. We have a new favorite!! My husband had a more than generous serving of spaghetti and meatballs and a salad. The sauce was beautifully balanced and the meatballs were tender and delicious. The accompanying roll was a wonderful surprise, not the typical hard, crusty roll, but soft and fresh. The salad was not only visually appealing, but had a delicious mix of fresh greens, tomato and an amazing dressing. My flatbread pizza was unique and perfect. There was a slight error in our order. What is noteworthy however, was the speed and grace with which it was corrected and resolved. Our server, Jaimee S. was delightful! She was attentive and friendly, a real asset to her employer! We’ll definitely be back, both for carry out and eat in.
Read more
Google
Went to eat. Lady who served us was wonderful. When my dad wanted to change tables the lady who brought out out appetizer got an attitude about the fact we changed tables... which turned into words with my dad. After she left patio she called us white trash... we left. Food looked good... but that experience left sour taste in our mouths.
Read more
Google
Funky, fun, casual Italian joint with a great menu and beers. They're most famous for their calzones, which are fantastic, but I also like their 8" pizzas. Just the right size with a long list of toppings to choose from. A great place for happy hour and to meet friends for dinner.
Google
Ordered a meats pizza with banana peppers. Took a bite and wondered where the toppings were. Found half the toppings UNDERNEATH the pizza but still no banana peppers. Also the Stromboli has been doughy in the middle the last few times I've had it.
Google
Explore more in Westerville
By cuisine
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: