Stuff-a-bagel

425 Montauk Hwy, 11795-4413 - West Islip
€€
★★★★★ ★★★★★
70/100
862 recommendations

Verified Dish

Add Missing Dish

70/100
Sluurpy Score
862 total reviews
Tripadvisor
3.5/5
19 reviews
Google
3.5/5
228 reviews
Foursquare
3.5/5
15 reviews
Facebook
2.6/5
1 reviews
Grubhub
3.0/5
18 reviews
Doordash
4.0/5
386 reviews
Uber eats
4.0/5
51 reviews
Menupix
1.5/5
6 reviews
Restaurantji
2.6/5
87 reviews
Postmates
4.0/5
51 reviews
🚚 Delivery 🥡 Takeout Wheelchair accessible

💬 What people say

Prices 17 Breakfast 14 Roll 13 Egg sandwich 11 Bacon 8 Cream cheese 8 Money 5 Order 4

Contact Information

📞 Phone: +1 631-661-7646
📍 Address: 425 Montauk Hwy, West Islip

🕐 Opening Hours

Closed Opens at 05:00 AM
Monday1 05:00 AM - 02:00 PM
Tuesday2 05:00 AM - 02:00 PM
Wednesday3 05:00 AM - 02:00 PM
Thursday4 05:00 AM - 02:00 PM
Friday5 05:00 AM - 02:00 PM
Saturday6 05:00 AM - 02:00 PM
Sunday7 05:00 AM - 02:00 PM

Google Reviews (9)

E

Erin Bell

a week ago
★★★★★ 5/5
good food, prices and service!!
Google
D

D HAHA

4 months ago
★★★★☆ 4/5
Great place to stop by and pick up some freshly made bagels before hitting the water to fish
Google
R

Robert Ricciardi

6 months ago
★★★★☆ 4/5
A little to expensive for me very clean and efficient. But I can get an egg sandwich for almost half the price at j&g deli in copaiuge
Google
C

Cristina Cutrone

a year ago
★★★★★ 5/5
The new management is wonderful! It’s VERY clean. Very friendly staff. Bagels are always good too! No complaints.
Google
S

Scott

2 years ago
★★★★★ 5/5
Great spot for bagels and really good cream cheese. Not the spot if you’re looking for a specialty coffee but they’ve got all the staples. We grabbed a bit of lox too and that was excellent.
Google
B

Brett Scholten

2 years ago
★★★★★ 5/5
Travel nurse from northern Michigan. They don't make bagels like this in Michigan. I've read the recent reviews and my opinion on the negative reviews here, are the customers suck, not the staff. Ive Been here almost every morning for the last 2 months with no complaints. Your sandwiches are awesome! Keep up the good work.
Read more
Google
P

Paul Hoffman

5 years ago
★★★★☆ 4/5
Good bagels. Good prices. Decent coffee. I didn't always get what I ordered, so I started writing it down on paper and handing it to the counter staff. Always check your order when you get it. Other than that, they are quick and easy to see from 25.+
Google
N

Nash Birnholz

7 years ago
★★★★☆ 4/5
When we first moved to town we went to every bagel place in the area. The taste of the bagels here far exceeded the rest. The owner is a jerk (rude to customers and employees) and there's plenty of staff turnover but many there are nice. Losing Billy hurts, but the quality of the product remains high.
Read more
Google
E

Evan Andersen

8 years ago
★★★★☆ 4/5
Best bagel spot in the area. Don't let others one-off reviews scare you away from this place. Been coming here for years and have tried bagels from a lot of other shops in the surrounding area and these are the top. Bigger than average bagels and perfectly chewy.
Google

📊 Compare with Other Restaurants

Restaurant Score Google Tripadvisor Reviews
Bella Cucina 96% 4.4/5 - 1,510
Dunkin' 71% 3.7/5 - 258
Bagels Buzz 76% 4.3/5 4.0/5 7,155
Mona Lisa of long Island 90% 4.5/5 - 86
Dunkin' Donuts 70% 3.5/5 3.0/5 265
SomePlace Else 84% 4.2/5 - 64

Other Restaurants in West Islip

Bella Cucina

⭐ 95.3 (1510 reviews)

Teresa's Pizza

⭐ 95.0 (88 reviews)

Hometown Heroes

⭐ 94.0 (636 reviews)

Paradise Saloon

⭐ 91.3 (70 reviews)

Higbie Heros

⭐ 90.4 (600 reviews)

Mona Lisa Of Long Island

⭐ 90.0 (86 reviews)

Help us improve

← Back to all restaurants in West Islip

🍽️ Suggest a dish

⚠️ Report error

🚫 Report closed

Do you confirm that Stuff-a-bagel has permanently closed?