Connie's was fantastic. Though it was busy, the waitresses did an amazing job. People were in an out wait time was minimal and the food was great. Getting a loaded milkshake is a must. I got the suger cookies on, and it was loaded with all types of Christmas themed yummy. Will definitely be going back!
After seeing a post on Facebook about their Loaded Milkshakes, I had to stop. Amy was our waitress and was exceptional. I couldn't finish the milkshake, Amy gave me a box and then wrapped up glass for me to take it home.
Top marks all around! Beautiful diner with spectacular food. Best patty melt I've ever had.
There isn’t a better diner in all of the Finger Lakes region! Value is terrific, and the food is so yummy! They only take cash. It gets really busy. The desserts are the best!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Our hotel front desk staff suggested this diner for our family to visit and have dinner. We loved it!
Food was delicious with hefty portions!
I got the breaded, deep-fried haddock with cole slaw.
The service was great, fast, and friendly.
We recommend it!
Very sweet little diner. Affordable prices, nice atmosphere, really takes you back. The food was good, but nothing super special. The eggs were a little soggy, as if the vegetables sweat within them, but they were good. The French toast was really good too and the hash browns were super crunchy. This place is cash only, though. So be aware of that! I think it’s worth a visit for the atmosphere.
This place is great. We stopped at around 2 pm on a Saturday and the place was packed. It was well worth the wait. Food and service were really good. If it would be closer than 5 hours from home, we would be back regularly. It will be a stop we make every time we are in town. More on the menu I would like to try. Servers were all very friendly and there was no shortage of staff. The milkshakes are definitely worth trying.
Felicia Truley (biiifelicia)
+5
This diner will always be my favorite! My husband and I were visiting some family in Geneva, we currently live in Virginia. so we had to stop by for a quickie and he got a garbage plate. Always delicious and love the atmosphere here! We have to make time for Connie’s when we come into town!
Wife and I went for a date night. Food is great as well as the staff. Portions are HUGE. Price is responsible for the amount of food you get
Can't get enough!! Amazing food, crazy good desserts, great prices, HUGE PORTIONS and such a friendly staff!!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Waterloo
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes