Yesterdays Irish Pub

We were happily surprised to discover this charming Irish Pub. Straight away Peggy, cheerful wife of the owner, and friendly Erin, a server, waited on us hand and foot. The hearty scrumptious beef stew hit the spot. The light warm bread was the perfect accompaniment. We have to say Peggy's chocolate covered peanut butter pie was out of this world. Thanks so much for a wonderful experience at Yesterday's. I especially enjoy looking at all the interesting photos and reading some Irish lyrics etc.. which adorned the walls. We hope to come back one day and highly recommend that others enjoy Yesterday's too.

Another trip here today. Brunch time. We didn't stray from our usual fish and chips/Reuben sharefest. Both sooo good. The menu is lengthy though! Kids had chicken fingers and fries.(I also ate one, it was good! :]) Also had peanut butter pie and the kids had chocolate chip pie(also stole a bite of that and it was great). They are gonna be jumping tomorrow! Great food, great nostalgic decor and our hosts Peggy and John were very sweet and attentive. We all had a great time. We didn't imbibe but they have a full bar. No pics of the food because we devoured it.

Good food, interesting atmosphere and good service. This quaint pub in Warwick, NY is a place we would go back to. I would not call it impressive but a good meal for the price. The portions were a good size. We ordered chicken fingers for each of our two kids, my husband got the roast beef with bacon sandwich, and I got the apple goat cheese salad. The salad cold have used some chicken for the price which is why I give it 4 stars. This place does take you back to another time.

We love to come to Yesterday’s for the small town feel and the great food. Hands down the best burger in Warwick. Everything is fresh & tasty. The owners are down to earth, hardworking people and have stayed so positive throughout such a tough couple of years. We are looking forward to supporting them at their new location!

Went for a quick drink last night but right now base on the state law you have to get something to eat in order to order a drink, (appetizers not included) it must be an entree. The server suggested a burger or chicken tenders, so I went with the tenders because I wasn't that hungry. Can't go wrong with Yesterdays!!!

The food was okay, the communication was not. This is the second time I've been here. The first time I was here the food was excellent. I got the duck de jour then. It came with a maple syrup glaze. Very tasty. I was craving it again. It said on the menu to ask about what glaze was available as the special. I mentioned to the waitress what I had the last time. She said, "I believe it's the same thing." It wasn't. It was pineapple. Not something I would have paired with duck. If I would have known that I would have gotten something different. I didn't want to send it back and waste the food so I stuck it out. This time the duck was overcooked. It wasn't like that the last time. Not sure if a different chef wad on duty? Still a lot of money for a meal I didn't care for. The waitress checked in to ask how everything was. I tried to share some feedback, but she was too quick and interpreted it as "all good." I don't want to be too critical as this place does seem to do good business, but this wasn't the best experience in comparison to our last visit. My friend ordered the Ahi Tuna, asked for medium. It came out medium rare. So, it leads me to the impression the chef on duty was doing their own thing? Idk. I'd be willing to go back, but may wait a while and next time be more determined about getting and giving feedback to the wait staff.