Sugar Shack
301 1st St, 31328-8752 - Tybee Island
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#31 of 39 restaurants in Tybee Island
Updated on
€€€
American
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
60/100
Data Completeness
67/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🥡
Takeout
🍽️
Dine-in
🚚
Delivery
♿
Wheelchair accessible
📊 Popular Times
Not busy
Moderate
Very busy
Contact Information
📞
Phone:
+1 912-786-4482
🌐 Website:
http://www.tybeesugarshack.com
📍
Address:
301 1st St, Tybee Island
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
1,549
Google reviews
We rented a golf cart / side by side for a couple hours to check out the back streets of Tybee Island. The lady that rented it to me was very thorough in the explanation of safety responsibilities and the laws on the island prohibiting where you cannot go with this motorized cart. We paid about $95 bucks for 2 hours or we could have gotten it for 24 hours for like $187 or something. Everything was great though. Just a quick heads up, you have to stop and put gas in before you take it back so factor 10 minutes of your time for that.
Read more
Google
We stayed around the corner and visited 1-2 per day. The waffles are great, my husband loved their coffee with two shots of vanilla, he also loved their red velvet cake ice cream, and I loved their sugar cone with chocolate peanut butter overload. Angie was so friendly and she recognized us our second visit and remembered things we had mentioned before…seemed like she knew everyone who came in and everyone loved her!
Read more
Google
Cute little ice cream and candy store! The outside decor is great and perfect for photo ops. The only downside is the gals serving the ice cream aren’t super friendly.
My soon loved the mint chocolate chip and loved sitting at the ice cream table!
Google
Everything was great! The milkshakes were the best part! Riley was our server and was very attentive and nice. Kelly, the manager, was great!
Google
The Sugar Shack is about two blocks away from the AirBnB we are staying at and we saw it our first night on the island. Yesterday was a scorcher and after being on the beach for about an hour, my wife and I decided to run in and grab an ice cream cone. We’d not tried this location before, but we are certainly glad we did. The place was fairly busy with a large line at the counter. There are a few parking spaces for the business in a side lot and on the other side of the building, but other than that, it’s paid parking. We still had time left from our beach parking so that wasn’t really an issue. There is a covered area out front that has small colorful tables with cute chairs in the shape of ice cream cones. Inside the shop, there is a large candy selection and the decor is fun and kind of retro. This reminded me of the long defunct Heidi’s Ice Cream back home in Pompano Beach, FL. This place has a real mom and pop old time beach ice cream shop vibe going on and I loved it. The staff were super busy but polite and they had a special flavor called Key Lime Pie that we both tried. Wow! It really was like a Key Lime pie. The ice cream was smooth and velvety with a creamy texture (it will melt instantly when you emerge into the heat!), but it had the right mixture of tart and sweet that a legit Key Lime Pie should have. There were plentiful amounts of graham cracker crust in the ice cream, too. It was truly a treat! I regret that I had to take a picture of a partially eaten cone when I got back to the car, but it was so good that a photo of the cone was almost an afterthought! Just understand that the cone was far more ample before I made it back to my vehicle!
Read more
Google
Loved this place! Definitely an expensive experience, but the staff were very nice and the ice cream was even better! I'm pretty sure its 24 flavors and they all looked yummy. I got a one scoop waffle cone, which honestly was like a two scoop, for $6.25ish dollars. Very good! I'd definitely eat here again, it's not too overpriced where I wouldn't come because it's to be expected, but the amount of ice cream they give you for one scoop is nice! They also have a little candy shop right next through a door on the other side of the shop where you can fill up bags of candy! That's really cool! Anyway, I recommend this place! It was clean, organized, and an overall good quality shop!
Read more
Google
One of the most eye-catching, cutest ice cream shops I've seen. There is every type of candy you can think of along with multiple ice cream flavors. The outside seating area has the MOST ADORABLE table & chair sets I've ever seen! It was a great stop to cure our sugar teeth 😉
Google
Great place for ice cream with cute seating outside. The scoops are huge and delicious. My family enjoyed it!
Google
Stop by if you’re on Tybee looking for great ice cream, endless supply of candy, and family fun atmosphere. Really enjoyed the visit and they also have an affordable golf cart rental for those who really want to sight see and travel on Tybee.
Google
Really good ice cream. I got the coconut ice cream and it was amazing. The staff are nice and the place is really clean. They have plenty of candy options along with lots of ice cream options. It gets pretty busy at certain times as it is a popular place though so keep that in mind. I would recommend stopping it was really good.
Read more
Google
Explore more in Tybee Island
By cuisine
By specialty
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: