I love this place. This is not where you go for fine dining but if you want awesome, I mean awesome pizza, go to Umberto's. They are always busy but they are always fast. I tell everyone this is a must try for pizza!
Unberto's has been a great hidden treasure for a while. That did move out of the hideout, but their pizza is still my absolute favorite. Not a fancy place and you certainly won't find someone educating you on an extensive beer selection, but you will have an amazing pizza at a great price.
One of the greats in Tulsa for me! I love non-chain pizza places, they always make the best. Really good pizza and the garlic knots are redonkulous!!
Pizza by the Slice!!! Great pizza and garlic knots are a must but you better like garlic they give you plenty. Great food at a great price, best bang for your buck, when it comes to pizza. The owner is probably one of the friendliest in Tulsa.
Michelle Talvitie Stanley
+5
Best pizza I've had in years and years. Only thing I can think would make them, is one closer to home. We drove 85 miles to Tulsa for medical treatments and we usually try to stop in there for pizza.
Geoffrey Shon Brewster
+4.5
Best local pizza in town. They deliver. Are reasonably priced. And the knots are to die for. Authentic NYC style pizza that you'll need to fold over.
Overall it was pretty good. Garlic knots where great. The pizza couldve used a bit more sauce . The single slices are plenty big enough
Great Pizza!!!!!. Love the crust! Been coming to this place for sometime now. Owner is nice and the pizza is IMO, the best pizza in Tulsa!!!
Pizza by the slice. Last week I was in the area, and stopped in to order a couple of slices of their sausage pizza. For those who haven't tried Umberto's, their slices are large and prepared very well. I got there about 11am, and was the 1st to order in house. My pizza came out quickly and was very, very good. Nice amount of sausage and cheese and their pizza sauce had a nice flavor. I had to work to finish both slices, and left a happy guy. Give them a try!
Supreme Pizza. 20 inches of "supreme" deliciousness!
I remember when this place opened in Tulsa at a different location more than 20 years ago. The pizza then was amazing with a completely different flavored pepperoni than I've ever had and the freshest ingredients I've ever had in a pizza. Umberto's has gone through many changes, and the pizza is still great. It's my favorite pizza place in Tulsa. There's a wide choice these days for New York style pizza, but nothing beats a Supreme from Umberto's. It's the best.
I’ve been here a couple times now and I love the pizza here. It looks simple, but sometimes simple is all you need. I love that you can order by the slice and trust me, one slice will fill you up quite a bit. I also tried their calzone and it was the best I’ve ever had. The red sauce that comes with it is super tasty and they don’t skimp on the fillings. Definitely check this place out if you want no frills, quality NY style pizza.
Finally tried this local place. The pizza was delicious and outstanding. My love ordered the garlic knots and you can see they put like an entire can of minced garlic on it. We absolutely love garlic and this was wayyyyyy to much and ruined it. Pizza joint was cool but outside of ordering not much small talk or atmosphere building going on.
Decent slice of pizza. Taste was mediocre but the ingredients seemed very fresh.
This is the best pizza in town! I love that they do by the slice pizza and that it is cooked immediately. Everything is fresh and delicious!
Really good NY style pizza. I bought by the slice and really enjoyed it, even though it was reheated. The crust had a good chew/crunch ratio and the sauce was not too sweet. They also are not shy with the toppings. The guy next to me had a calzone that looked really good. I think if I would have ordered a whole pie fresh it would have been an easy 5 stars. Worth noting that the prices and service we're also really good.
Like wow! Haven’t had that good of a pizza ever! One slice is bigger than my boyfriends hand. We went for Father’s Day and tried the meat, pepperoni, Hawaiian with jalapeños, garlic knots and the wings… all were delicious. Just two gentlemen working and they whipped us up our food fast and it was piping hot! Couldn’t say anything better than amazing! Highly recommend anyone stopping here
Generous toppings that manage great flavor without the need for a ton of red sauce. I haven't met anyone that didn't love the pizza or calzones here.
Delicious pizza and calzones. The pizza was made fresh. I watched the man throw the dough in the air after I ordered. If you're craving pizza and are tired of the same old same old come here. Also, you can get it by the slice so this is a great option for a quick lunch break 🍕🍕🍕
What a pizza!!! I have known this place for little big over 25 years. Still the same delicious New York style pizza. If you live in Tulsa/Broken Arrow area you should try it. Don't expect a fancy place, expect one of the best pizza in town.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Tulsa
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes