Review Mahogany Prime Steakhouse - Tulsa

Celebrating a birthday here with family and had a wonderful experience. Shawn (or Sean?) was incredibly attentive and humorous for our visit so very high praise to him. We kind of sampled several parts of the menu, all generally with great success. The steaks were cooked to perfection. We had the beet and orange salad as an app and also some oysters for dinner. The oysters were ok, I wouldn't go out of my way for them in the future, but they were fine. The Key lime with pecan crust was very good... but at that point in the meal I definitely felt like a food coma 🥴🥴🥴 We're not Tulsa natives but would definitely come back for a future visit.

Food was absolutely incredible. Went here on a company function and got the special, Wagyu from Japan. It was the single best piece of meat I have ever tasted. Amazing wait staff, they are very friendly and the atmosphere was calm and nice! Of course it was ABSURDLY expensive, but that's why you're coming here, right?

It was our first time to eat here. My wife and I were celebrating our wedding anniversary. It was a little difficult to find and I suggest you follow your GPS. You have to make reservations and if you are over 5 minutes late, they get cancelled. I suggest you give yourself plenty of time in order to be on time. The atmosphere when we walked in was great but we were escorted back to a room in the back where other couples were eating. The atmosphere in the room was blah. No exciting things to watch, no windows to look out just kinda dim. I was disappointed with the atmosphere considering what we were about to spend for dinner. They have two people from the wait staff who take care of you. The speed of service is awesome. The speed of the food is great and the flavors were delicious. We received a complimentary box of chocolates for our anniversary. This was really nice of them. We couldn't decide on one dessert so we had a trio of desserts. Overall it was a 5 star experience with the only exception of the back room needing to feel more lively and open. Thank you for a wonderful anniversary dinner to remember ❤️.

Simply amazing. First time we've been there and can't wait to go back. Restaurant missed nothing...service was knowledgeable and friendly. Food was excellent. Be sure to order the bacon wrapped scallops and the Mahogany cheesecake. Delicious.

This place is next level! Ive never dined at such a superb place place. The food was phenomenal, the service incredible, the atmosphere exquisite! Great place for dates, business dinners, and friendly dining. The creme brulee cheesecake was out of this world!

Ate with a large party in the bar area, which was very loud. First time back to Mahogany in 22 years, and the food was mostly underwhelming. Our bill was over $1200, so expectations were high. The appetizer platter was ho-hum. The calamari was rubbery and chewy. The large peel and eat shrimp was excellent. Their dynamite shrimp pales in comparison to the same at In the Raw or bang bang shrimp at Bonefish. The lobster on the seafood tower was okay, and i didn't try the oysters. With that said, my filet was divine...one of the best steaks I've had...cooked perfectly. However the peppercorn sauce was not good, so I'm glad i got it on the side. The chive whipped potatoes were fantastic. Bourbon prices were okay. Overall, not an experience that has me wanting to go back, especially for the coin we dropped on that meal. If i simply want a great steak with a salad and potatoes, i might return.

Kate and Nate made our 1st Anniversary amazing. The service, food and the special chocolate treat from the General Manager were spectacular.

The atmosphere was awesome! The wait staff was awesome! The service was awesome! What can I say, it's an AWESOME dining experience. Oh yeah, dessert is awesome! I do advise making reservations so you can get right in to a great table!! Please don't tell anybody about this place let's keep this a secret between you and me!!!!!

This is truly a five-star experience. From the moment we walked in to the moment we left, the staff went above and beyond with their hospitality. The establishment is incredibly professional. We had a reservation for our wedding anniversary and were seated promptly. We never had to ask for a water refill (never even had to THINK about a refill) because someone was always there to take care of every need before we even knew we needed it. We started off with two cocktails, a watermelon and an orangecicle, which were both perfectly balanced. The cocktails were also priced very fairly, compared to other restaurants in the area. Next we tried the lobster cargot and dynamite shrimp. Both were heavenly, but the lobster cargot really blew us away. If it was the ONLY item on the menu, this would still easily be our favorite restaurant. Next, my husband and I shared the surf and turf trio (I don’t remember the official name of the order, something-trio) in which we got medium rare filet mignon, lobster, and crab. The chefs kindly prepared our order on two plates. When the food was brought out, two staff members waited with pen lights while we cut into our filets ensure they were prepared correctly. Everything was delicious, but again, the lobster was better than anything I’ve ever tasted. Melted butter was placed on the table, but the lobster was prepared so perfectly that butter wasn’t even needed. Complete perfection. We cannot wait to return for the lobster. We NEVER order dessert anywhere. But after our experience with the rest of the food, we knew we had to try it here. It was especially convincing when our waitress explained each item in detail. We ordered a cheesecake item that was not featured on the menu. It was coated in sugar and torched. It was paired with chocolate, cream and berries. It was absolutely incredible. I’m thinking about ordering it for pickup, as I’m writing this review… before we left, the executive manager came around and introduced herself. She came back shortly after and gifted us a small box of locally made chocolate (Glacier) which was also very delicious. All of the staff was gracious and kind. From start to finish, this was a perfect experience and I highly recommend this establishment to any and all.

Awesome customer service!! I ordered take out. The staff were soo pleasant and polite! The food was awesome!! I ordered the Chicken Marsala, mashed potatoes, Brussel sprouts and it came with 2 dinner rolls. First off, I am not a bread person but those rolls were great; 2nd the Brussel sprouts were the best I have ever had. This place is pricey but it is well worth it! The valet attendant went above and beyond for, they also were very pleasant and polite!! It’s refreshing to get satisfactory customer service but they were extraordinary!! I will dine in soon. When I pulled up to the take out parking spot my waiter came out and informed me my order would be out soon. He asked if I wanted a courtesy drink,, soda or water.

We all had filets with chive garlic mashed potatoes and asparagus. The steaks were superb, the potatoes and asparagus likewise. The staff kept a close eye on us, refilling our water glasses numerous times. Since both Marcy and I are hard of hearing now, our waitress sat down and patiently explained the specials and menu. If you're passing through or even living in Tulsa try this place. Be prepared for steep prices, though; it's worth it.

My wife and I went there a couple of days ago for our anniversary dinner. Hands down the best meal and service we've ever had! The staff were perfect, from those who seated us to those who waited on us, to the manager stopping by to wish us a happy anniversary and inquire about the meal. Our wait staff, Sean and Christa, were fantastic, offering spot-on advice and recommendations and then serving flawlessly. The self-proclaimed Waterboy, Paul, was perhaps the nicest young man we have ever met... he was kind, generous, professional and very engaging. The food was fantastic, best steak ever. This restaurant has customer service and quality of product down like no other...

Celebrated our 5th wedding anniversary here this evening! The staff was wonderful and the food fantastic! We started with the lobster cargot appetizer and it was superb! The steak and salmon were also great, but dessert, the chocolate cake, made our entire meal! We even got a little gift for our anniversary! We will definitely be returning!

Brought my mother-in-law in Sunday to celebrate Mother's Day. Assuming dinner would be super busy, we made a reservation online for 8:30 (and I embarrassingly didn't realize they closed at 9 �) The entire staff treated us so well, despite the fact that we kept them well after close. Everything was immaculate and the food was perfect, despite being the last meals to come out of the kitchen. Sean & Krista treated us better than any server I've ever had, and made the experience perfect. My MIL was super impressed by everything and said it was the best meal she had ever had! Thank you all for never breaking form- as a server myself, I know that guests being oblivious to the closing time is often irritating. I really appreciate your role in making Mother's Day perfect!

My mil and I wrapped up my birthday trip to the area here last night. It was spectacular. The food and service was awesome. Everyone was friendly and extremely helpful. I remember David and Olivia were two of the 4-5 people tending to us. I had a couple champagne fusions and they were delicious. We both ordered the house salad and filets, shared the button mushrooms and spinach, and had cheesecake with berries for dessert to finish the meal. It was worth a trip back to the area to enjoy again.

We celebrated our wedding anniversary at this restaurant. I've heard lots of reviews, mainly how perfect everything was. We were greeted, and walked to our table. We had three different waiters. Which all three were absolutely amazing. Everyone who worked there, had a job to do. The teamwork was great. We were not pressured into drinks or foods. They told us about the menu, specials, and answered our questions. Everything was perfect. I did assume the dress code would have been business casual. So we dressed accordingly. I did see people in shorts, t-shirts, and jeans. I've attached pictures of our dinner. From the Fried calamari, lobster /crab bisque, 21 Oz cowboy Ribeye, 14oz Ribeye, roasted Brussel sprouts, and chive whipped mashed potatoes.

My husband brought me here for our anniversary while we were visiting Tulsa. The meal was excellent and the service was amazing. My steak came out a bit over done. The manager came right over to the table, apologized and brought a new one out that was perfectly done. I would highly recommend!

I won a gift card for Valentines from our apartment comlex. We finally used it in March. It was awesome from the first minute we walked in the door. They seated us and asked us if we cared for a drink and gave several suggestions. They catered to everything that you could possibly think that you'd want. The food was amazing the side portions were huge and they were constantly so attentive to make sure that you didn't need for anything. Even though we didn't order whole lot it was so much that we couldn't eat it all and they quickly asked us if we would like it to go they quickly whisked it away and brought it back in a nice to go bag. I felt as though somehow I had been transported into a bigger city like New York for a night out. It is one of the best restaurants in Tulsa by far as far as friendly and courteous and wanting to meet your needs. My husband and I will be going back there to celebrate either our anniversary or Christmas.

Everything was wonderful from the service to the food. Highly recommend. First class

We celebrated our anniversary by having dinner at Mahogany’s. Beautiful atmosphere and good food. The service was a bit overwhelming with multiple servers hovering and jumping at the smallest thing. It sounds strange to say there was too much service but.....I’ll just say they were over-staffed.

Celebrating our anniversary and couldnt have asked for better food..we had a 8oz filet and lobster dinners, a HUGE baked potato, crab cakes for appetizer. Cant say enough on how good everything tasted and the presentation was excellent. They even had one of my wifes favorite wines. Staff was very attentive, fantastic job to everyone!

We had a great time with the family. They have the best staff who is on their A game. The menu is awesome and the food is even better. Can't wait to go back the next time we are in town.

I was there last night to celebrate my daughters birthday, the food was excellent, the steak cooks perfectly, the best part that I love the most is the chocolate cake for dessert and the chocolate martini, it is the best chocolate martini that I had so far, one thing is lucking is the wowness of the ambiance, for the price, I expect wow effect when I enter your restaurant,my opinion needs more upgrade😊

The food is very good The service is great My only issue is my steaks are either too raw or burned :/ As soon as that's fixed it will be perfect

The food was amazing. The service was TOP NOTCH. I was amazed at every level. You have amazing staff that was professional and comical. This was my first experience and I will definitely be a repeat customer. Amazing food. Amazing service.

Our meals where fantastic our servers Amity and Asher where amazing and the Brandy Alexander Ice is a must try for dessert. Can’t wait to go back!!! Thanks for a wonderful night out