We've lived around the corner from Geno D's for 19 years and have been there and ordered take out from them too many times to count. Everything I've had there is great. If you're going for fancy dining, go somewhere else. I like to pay for great food...not fancy dining and this place has great food. Their subs are second to none and they have great pizza. Their deliveries are always on time and the people are friendly. Yes, there are many other Pizzarias in the area but we like it here. If you've had a bad experience here, lighten up and try them again. If you have another bad experience, it's probably you.
I like my pizza with extra cheese and the crust very well done. It was perfect with lots of cheese and the crust was perfectly crispy. They don't have a problem with special orders. So many other places completely missed the mark.
Geno D's has quickly become our go-to pizza place after moving to the area. The food is consistently fantastic, but more importantly, the service is warm & welcoming. That can be very hard to find these days. We really appreciate it. Thank you Geno D's
We moved back to NJ a little over a year ago and luckily Geno D's was the first Pizza place we tried since being back and it's hands down better than anything else we've had in the area. The garlic knots are a big family favorite also. I'm not from NJ originally and I never really understood my husband's search for a "decent slice" until now. Besides good quality we're really happy with the pricing as well as the service all in all a great spot!
Grew up down the road from this place. I moved elsewhere in the US in 2004, and I still rate pizza by comparing it to the pizza from here. They are pretty much the best.
The décor is just what you'd expect from a pizza place that's been there since it was the only strip mall around. If you're looking for some kind of 4-star dining experience, you shouldn't be eating at a pizza place anyway.
I do miss the pinball machines :)
They have the best buffalo pizza around. No other pizzeria comes close. The only thing is you have to ask them to add the bleu cheese. They used to put it on the pizza but for some reason they stopped. The only reason I didn't give them 5 stars is even asking for the bleu cheese to be added on, it comes on the side. Aside from that all the food is good and reasonably priced. They sell Pepsi products just a heads up.
I have been going to Geno D's for 27 years... The speciality pizza's are great, the hot subs are always excellent BUT I have always said, for the very best sub, no-one does it better then Geno's... I can be a pain, I like what I like and never has anyone ever had a problem with special orders.. Nicole, you're the best...
My first time here was a few days ago. Everyone work there was very friendly. The food was great! I will definitely be returning the next time I am in Brick!!
Great food for a great price. Every time. Friendly people. Lots of choices. Only place I like everything I have.
The food was delicious, Staff is pleasant and friendly made us feel special. Will definitely go back.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Toms River
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes