New York New York Pizza - Carrollwood

New York New York Pizza - Carrollwood, Tampa 10434 N Dale Mabry Hwy - Tampa

Now open

87/100
Give a rating

VIEW MENU

VIEW MENUS
Reviews
Call
menu

MENU↗
Timetable
Make a reservation
Order online
Share
Map
Ratings
Add photo

VIEW MENU

 Reviews Call Timetable Make a reservation Order online Add photo Share Map Ratings

What's your favorite New York New York Pizza - Carrollwood's dish?

Ratings and reviews

87
/100
Based on 2044 ratings and reviews
Updated

Ratings of New York New York Pizza - Carrollwood

TA

Trip
Last update on 02/01/2024
4,5
4 Reviews
Google
Google
Last update on 01/01/2024
4,3
638 Reviews
Facebook
Facebook
Last update on 07/09/2020
4,8
2 Reviews

G

Grubhub
Last update on 14/07/2023
4,0
951 Reviews

MW

Menu with price
Last update on 07/09/2020
4,3
90 Reviews

UE

Uber eats
Last update on 14/07/2023
4,0
63 Reviews

S

Slice
Last update on 15/05/2020
4,7
236 Reviews

Menu New York New York Pizza - Carrollwood

  • Popular Items
    • Build Your Own Pizza (12")
    • Build Your Own Pizza (18")
    • Buffalo Wings
    • Build Your Own Pizza (16")
    • Build Your Own Pizza (14")
  • Appetizers
    • Fried Mushroom
    • Fried Mozzarella
    • Fried Zucchini
    • Chicken Tenders
    • Shrimp Basket
  • Salads
    • Garden Salad (Small)
    • Garden Salad (Large)
    • Caesar Salad (Small)
    • Caesar Salad (Large)
    • Greek Salad (Small)
  • . . .
  • Browse the menu

Available menus

Reviews

Facebook
Mario Joseph Conte
+5
Great place awesome food slices are huge highly recommended.
5
Naida Tangredi
+5
First time here. I was struck by two things right away:the huge size of slices for an awesome price and the way the staff made you feel like family. I had a cheese slice and a white slice and both were absolutely perfect. They definitely take pride in their food. This will be my new go to place for pizza. Wendy is a treasure! Highly recommended!!
5
Colorado Home Roofing
+5
NY NY pizza is awesome. I order take out all the time and I must say they never let me down. The pizza itself is delicious, with a crispy,crunchy crust. I order the Supreme XL 18" alot(see picture below)$20. I also get a pepperoni pizza sometimes. They have gluten free options as well. I have had the Greek salad(Again great). NY NY pizza has meatballs(my favorite) as a side or dinner option. They have special on pizza slices and a drink, plus different choices of pizza and Buffalo wings. They are on time with the order. Never had to wait for it. Staff is friendly and nice. They always say Thank you. I like that interaction. Prices are very good. Loyalty program. YAY!! I go to the one on Dale Mabry(Carrollwood) Enjoy!!
5
Sheryl Santos-Hatchett, PhD
+5
We just wanted a slice of NY style pizza in an eat in place and we got it here! They have a great menu of all sorts of food but we just wanted a slice! Very pleasant place with tables to sit down.
5
Jacqui Matute
+5
Wow! Real NY pizza. Brings back childhood memories walking down Liberty Ave with my family with a giant folded slice of hot cheese pizza. Excellent flavor, perfectly baked, and genuine NY style.
5
Anand R
+5
Very nice Pizza. I went here to try the slice Pizzas and ordered the Cheese Pizza. It's economical as of now and wish they don't increase the price at least in the near future. The toppings cost extra but it's still worth the price. Very tasty and yummy. Would visit here again.
5
Keshia-N-Love
+5
The you g lady who took my order was polite, very patience and went above and beyond to make sure my order was correct as she did for everyone. The staff was friendly with each other the restaurant was clean and it only took ten minutes for my pizza to be done everything was fresh and delicious 😋
5
Colin Freeman
+5
great pizza everything about it reminds me of ct/jersey. consistent cooked to perfection each time. ive been coming here for months and Wendy is the absolute greatest treats me like family and everyone else that walks in. I even sit down and enjoy my slices where I would never eat alone at other establishments. Cant say enough about this place.
5
Michael Perez
+5
I’m sitting in the restaurant as I write this to let everyone know the food as amazing! Freshly made, delicious chicken Alfredo pizza and the free gift for a new customer just added to the great experience. Thank you staff for a real NY style pizza and you will see us again soon!
5
byd3k
+5
Being from NJ, pizza was great. We had great, personal service dining in. My only concern was that the AC was either broken or overworked since FL is experiencing an unusually hot July. It does appear that most of their business is take-out versus dine in based upon having a small dine in area. If I lived in that area, I would go definitely go back!
5
Sam Medina
+5
I had a couple slices of pepperoni pizzas and they were huge. Not bad for around 8 bucks , including a soft drink. In New York you can find brick oven pizza at a dollar a slice but not as huge as the pizzas here and not served with love from the warm staff here at Ny Ny Pizza. I recommend this place if you’re looking for pizza that nearly emulates the hot and savory slices of authentic NY slices. 5 stars all day.
READ ALL REVIEWS

Description

Timetable

Now Open
Monday:
11:00 AM - 09:45 PM
Tuesday:
11:00 AM - 09:45 PM
Wednesday:
11:00 AM - 09:45 PM
Thursday:
11:00 AM - 09:45 PM
Friday:
11:00 AM - 09:45 PM
Saturday:
11:00 AM - 09:45 PM
Sunday:
11:00 AM - 09:45 PM

Order online with

G

Grubhub

Read the reviews on

TA

Trip
Google
Google
Facebook
Facebook

MW

Menu with price

UE

Uber eats

Info

Compare the best restaurants near New York New York Pizza - Carrollwood

bianca Sluurpy rate Google rate Facebook rate
TA

New York New York Pizza - Carrollwood

 88 4.3 4.8 4.5
Jubao Palace Noodle Bar 89 4.3 4.8 4
Planet Smoothie 92 4.6
Starbucks 76 3.6 4
MOGE TEE TAMPA 70
Oronzo Italian 80 4.4 3.5
Subway 70 2.5
First Watch 70

Related restaurants

Urban Juice Company, Tampa

Urban Juice Company
Village Inn Restaurant, Tampa

Village Inn Restaurant
Lit Nutrition Tampa, Tampa

Lit Nutrition Tampa
Grain and Berry, Tampa

Grain and Berry
Coast Westshore, Tampa

Coast Westshore
Pizzeataly Wood Fired Oven, Tampa

Pizzeataly Wood Fired Oven

Our aggregate rating, “Sluurpometro”, is 87 based on 2044 parameters and reviews

If you need to contact by phone, call the number +1 813-443-4598

MAKE A QUESTION

SUBMIT
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use

1
Add review
Add photo
Make a question
Suggest restaurant