Reviews of Key Pizza

Syracuse, US

4.7
11 reviews
5
8
4
3
3
0
2
0
1
0
Google: 11
Filter by:
P
Paul Fritzen
Google a year ago
5.0
I was expecting cheap, disgusting gas station pizza but as I walked in the owner just put out some Chicken Riggies and Chicken Alfredo out and took a Chicken Bacon Ranch and a Pepperoni pizza out of the oven. He was genuinely proud of it all and offered me some pasta as a sample. I grabbed a bunch of the Alfredo for my lady and grabbed 2 slices of pizza for myself. The pizza was well made, just how I like it. The crust was a little chewy but not tough, rich and buttery but not greasy. Just the right amount of cheese and toppings. It was savory and filling without making me feel bloated. Better than most I've had around Syracuse. The Chicken Alfredo was savory and very cheesy. My lady said it was better than the Chicken Alfredo at a well known and popular local Italian Restaurant. I agree with her. I can't really speak for their services as a takout pizzeria, but for walking onto a gas station in the area it is in I was thoroughly impressed with the quality.
R
Ryan Seymour
Google a year ago
5.0
When I lived in Cuse, this was the only place open near me after midnight. Hands down the best gas station pizza next to what used to be the God Fathers pizza from Hess back in the day...
S
Sarah Honis
Google 2 months ago
5.0
I love this place for a few reason…the food is fast but good, the staff is nice, it’s open late, the deli ever, and I can get good food and gas for my car at the same time!
M
Mark Truex
Google 2 months ago
4.0
Great food for a reasonable price. The crispy breaded wings are my favorite wings PERIOD. The pizza is good, crispy on the bottom, which is a must for me. Will be back!
I
Ike Percio
Google 2 months ago
5.0
Philly cheese steak is their best item in my opinion. One of the best in Syracuse.
S
Shameka Senior
Google 3 months ago
5.0
The men are nice, the food is so good and it's definitely one of those quick stop after a night of fun to get good food at.
T
TEAM SHERBOURNE
Google 6 months ago
4.0
Inside an extremely expensive gas station! Food was decent! Quick!
L
Luis “Lou” Alvarez
Google 7 months ago
5.0
This is much more than just a Valero gas station. If you’re looking for a quick bite on the go, they have the best Chicken Riggy in town They also have pizza, wings and much more. Stop and you will not be disappointment oh, and the garlic knots are wonderful. And the owner is one of the kindest person you can meet and a great conversationalist. I give this five stars and stamped with approval.
B
Brian Horton
Google 7 months ago
4.0
It's good pizza and service. It's a old gas station that looks and feels outdated and dirty but the kitchens clean.
M
mrspillana
Google 8 months ago
5.0
This place really hit the spot for me tonight. Went in and needed two slices. Had some friendly banter with the staff and the pizza was excellent. Wish I ordered more food. Will definitely be back.
B
Brandon Bacon
Google 10 months ago
5.0
One of the most underrated restaurants for Pizza. The owner is very passionate about the food!