Gallaghers Pizza

Gallagher’s was one of our choices staying at the hotel we did. Pizza was a simple solution for a quick meal for our two families. I was so impressed with how good their pizza was! We ordered their supreme and it was easily one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. The staff was cordial and prompt with getting out order. Thanks for making our stay in Green Bay additionally great! We highly recommend their pizza.

Came in hungry and with high hopes, left full of disappointment. Never received the appetizer we ordered, sat for an hour after we ordered pasta dishes before the waitress told us the kitchen was swamped, but our food was almost done. Baked Mostoccioli was definitely not baked, and very watered down. Meatballs were clearly old. Chicken Tetrazzini barely had any chicken in it. Definitely will never return here.

Terrible service the two times a year we come here for a family birthday at this location. Waited 20 minutes and had to ask one of the servers if they could serve liquor in order to get a drink. Wouldn't even acknowledge that we existed or ask if we were helped. Pizza is pretty good though. Spaghetti usually always watery, but we never come to this location unless we have to attend the family event. I do have to give kudos to the waitress who served our party of about 22 this last visit with no help and was super speedy as much as was possible.

My wife placed an online order at 4pm with a future promised time of 5:15pm. It is now after 5:45pm and I am still standing here waiting for the pizza. She literally gave over an hour of advance notice and I am here over 34 minutes beyond the due time with no pizza in hand. I am standing with a group of 4 other people waiting for their orders, too. At $22 for a 14 inch pizza and very poor service, I do not see a reason to come back.

I know, I’m really picky about pizza, so I found It to be just so so. The atmosphere is a bit cold, service just OK. I’ve seen the commercials, my first visit here, don’t know if I would race back but the people I was with really liked it. Definitely child friendly if that’s what you’re looking for. Waitress could’ve been a little more professional when asked about the drink menu. She just answered that she didn’t drink but could’ve handled that a different way. Who’s in front or kind of strange, really scrunched together where you couldn’t get your legs under without touching those across. Again, Just a so-so experience. I know other pizza places I’d much rather go to.