Food excellent, service excellent, location excellent. Just so good. Wife and I got the ml chicken marsala and chicken pasta with the broccoli and loaded garlic knots. Both were amazing and the servings were great! Must go. Highly recommend
I used to LOVE I mean LOVE their chicken Marsala but the last three times I’ve ordered it it tastes only like wine. idk what’s been going on they either aren’t cooking the wine till evaporation or they’re trying to get people drunk off of it. Please bring the old Marsala back!!!
![5]( "Recensione")
We were staying at Kalahari Resort in the Poconos and we were looking for a place to get pizza. After searching google maps, we found Benny's. It was a about a 20 minute drive, and the reviews were good, so we took a chance on driving a little further. It was well worth the drive. We ordered a cheese pizza, a taco pizza, fries, and Chicken Marsala. The pizzas had amazing flavor, the fries were good, and the Chicken Marsala was excellent. The pizza crust was great, and the edge of the pizza was just right, not to thick, not thin, and it wasn't dried out like a lot of pizzas. We are from South Central PA, we have plenty of pizza restaurants in the area, but none of their pizzas compare to Benny's.
The staff was very friendly. It's a little off the beaten path, but worth the drive. The outside of building could use a refresh, which makes you wonder, but the inside is very nice and looks like it was updated recently. If we travel back to the area, we would dine at Benny's again.
We definitely recommend Benny's to anyone that is looking for great food at a good price.
Lovely local business that makes delicious Pizzas 🍕 and their dough is fantastic .
Don't let the outside appearance fool you this local restaurant is not just a pizza joint, their also servings up some fantastic pasta dishes. We had 4 different pasta dishes and everyone of them was made to perfection. The Penna al Volka was so flavorful that it matched what I've had in many high priced restaurants that charge twice as much. The menu has a good selection of items to pick from and the service was outstanding. I wish I lived in the area so I could go back and try every item on the menu.
Always get quality food. Good prices. Staff is great, delivery quick, pick up quick. Best pizza and food in the area hands down.
Best pizza around! 100/10 we had a plain and a buffalo chicken slice of pizza! It was perfect not super greasy, quality cheese, spot on portions, sauce was delicious, awesome prices, great crust texture!! Can’t go wrong!🙌 The staff was outstanding and super nice we had quality quick service. It’s very clean in there as well!!!!🍕 Definitely going back!
This my second only because I live a half hour away. The only thing that made it better than the first time asked for well dome....Perfect!
The pizza is around a 4.5 or 4.6 as far as taste and quality. Very friendly staff, fair pricing, nice pizzeria atmosphere. My only complaint was that the pizza was very floppy in the center, folding the slice would not have even helped with that. After you get past the 1st couple inches of the slice it is firm enough to pickup and enjoy without the toppings taking a nose dive. Next time I will ask to have it cooked well done. Great sauce, great tasting ingredients. I can't give it a 4 rating, so it must be a 5. Really good tasting pizza. I'll try more of their italian foods as time goes on (I've heard good things).
Between route 611 in Tannersville and route 209 in Broadheadsville you should dine at this hidden gem serving delicious Italian food& pizza, We opted for the the house special with four toppings. $20 for the large.
Sabrina was especially sweet and personable with her personal preparation of cannoli Zeppoli that were served HOT and delicious dessert.
Great chef & pizza maker "R" was hustling throughout the kitchen preparing all aspects of Italian specialties.
Loved it. Will definitely be back.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Stroudsburg
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes