A perfect menu for family friendly food. Fresh, hot pies to share. Also offers meatballs sandwiches and cheese steaks. Nice bar area inside. But the dining area on the bay is what really made the dinner extra enjoyable.
Amazing pizza with an unbeatable view! We got the Italian Stallion which was stacked with toppings under all the cheese. It was delicious, great crust, and sauce had a nice kick to it. Liked that we could just order a slice of plain pizza for the kid so we could enjoy a pizza with toppings and spice that we like. Excellent and timely service. I was skeptical initially based on previous reviews. We only came here so we could sit by the water, we were pleasantly surprised at how good it was. Def recommend!
Pricey but great food and service. Amazing sunset views from the outdoor dining area. It appears that boats can dock and dine here!
Leaving this review for the lovely server my friends and I encountered, Lily! Unfortunately, my order was made wrong several times which Lily tried her best to accommodate for. Whoever was back there cooking, it would be good to listen/ read the orders being placed so people aren’t left walking out without eating like I was. The manager on duty was nice as well. Overall very nice place to come eat (very neat and aesthetically pleasing) HUGE SHOUT OUT TO LILY THOUGH! You were amazing <3
I have gone to the ends of the earth trying new foods and restaurants and not a single one has been able to top Stone Harbor Pizza. I have chills coursing down my arms as I write this review. This is the only establishment I recommend to colleagues/family/friends. I even have the menu plastered on my living room wall. The staff is incredible.
Restaurant is dog friendly, food is great and not too expensive, and wait staff is pretty nice
I enjoy going to restaurants that get unfair beef from disgruntled ex workers (you don’t know the situation, as the situation should always remain confidential) or entitled folks (never satisfied or just bitter) and have people like that being proven wrong time and time again. Yes, especially at a time when many small businesses are struggling, this is still happening but they just don’t care.
My inner Dean Martin would say it only needs more gravy, and my own chutzpah/ego even made a polite suggestion about it. 😂 😘 But on our next nostalgia trek, I’d eat these meatballs again in Stone Harbor. And the waterfront view was beautiful. So good! Another wonderful memory together.
Went for lunch. Our waitress was amazing!
The food not so much. Not many things on the menu. We wanted to eat outside but it was really hot and sunny. We ate inside and it was freezing!
They were able to seat our large group with minimum wait. We had nice seats out on the deck. The food was fine. The seagulls seem to really love this place. They frequent quit often.
Best pizza on the island. Everything came out tasty and our service was great. It's super quiet in the off-season! Brianna was a wonderful server and we loved her upbeat, positive attitude.
The pizza was hot, fresh and clearly made with high-quality ingredients like San Marzano tomatoes and sliced buffalo mozzarella cheese. 2 large pizzas was perfect for 4 people and we had plenty of leftovers! The mozzarella sticks came out room temperature and are very overpriced for what they are, but it didn't ruin the experience.
Highly recommend getting your pizza fix here.
Pro Tips:
- If you have an allergy, try the gluten free personal pizza and add your own toppings (additional charge for toppings)
- Ask for a table outside by the water
- Try the simple, yet crispy white pizza with mozzarella, garlic
oil, olive oil ($15 or $19)
- It's not fancy outside, paper plates and plastic cups
- Definitely can get a table outside in the off-season
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Stone Harbor
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes