Jimmy's Pizza
100 Center Creek Rd, 32084-0022 - St. Augustine
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#337 of 486 restaurants in St. Augustine
Updated on
Pizza
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
60/100
Data Completeness
67/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
📷 Photos (3)
Photo 1 / 3
100%
Google Reviews
83
Google reviews
Absolutely FANTASTIC! Fresh, hot and affordable. excited to stumble across this family owned pizza place. The owners on site, super friendly. This will be a future stop again in road trips to come. highly recommend!!!!
Google
Definitely one of the best New York style pizza places in town. Friendly staff good service and fresh ingredients. Lots of other options than just pizza. Wings, pasta, salads and a variety of appetizers to create a whole meal for everyone. Support local business and enjoy the food.
Google
Great New York style pizza! Crust is not soggy, sauce is amazing and cheese is not greasy. They offer pizza by the slice and have a few tables to sit and eat. Subs, pasta, salad and a variety of appetizers. Nice people too!
Google
We love our neighborhood pizza, wing and salad staple.
Always hot, always fresh-
Support your local small businesses! The delivery drivers are always pleasant. So happy they are close to home!
Google
Thanks to a Facebook campaign to save Jimmy's, I discovered this gem of a mom & pop pizza shop. Their Pop Pop batter fried vegetables are incredible! The sauce and dough for their pizzas are total flavor bombs. I will definitely good back to help keep them going and hope everyone else does as well.
Google
Pizza and calzones are awesome. The young girls at the ovens and counter on Saturday evening were definitely more efficient than the daytime staff during the week. Best pizza in St. Augustine, they just need to have slices ready at lunchtime for a quick walk-in pick-up during lunch hour.
Google
Amazing pizza, the people who work there are so nice, and pretty good deals. they offer pizza by the slice, or a whole pie. There are a few table to sit down and eat. TBH on of the best pizza places around by far. I 100% recommend!
Google
Tried it for the first time. Got a stromboli to go and it was prepared promptly. It was tasty and I will be going back to try other items on the menu. Reluctant to go higher than 3 stars for the first visit. I suspect it go higher after trying other items and getting a better idea of their range of quality.
Read more
Google
Explore more in St. Augustine
By cuisine
By specialty
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: