Old Street Pub

92 E Main St, 11787-2886 - Smithtown
Recommended by Sluurpy: 2025 2024 2021
🏆 #30 of 84 restaurants in Smithtown
Updated on
€€ American Bar
★★★★★ ★★★★★
3.7/5
754 recommendations

Sluurpy Quality Index

PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
61/100
Data Completeness
67/100

Verified Dish

Add Missing Dish

3.7/5
Sluurpometro: 75/100
Sluurpy Score
754 total reviews
TA Trip
3.5/5
73 reviews
G Google
4.4/5
469 reviews
F Foursquare
3.5/5
31 reviews
F Facebook
4.0/5
160 reviews
YP Yellow pages
3.0/5
1 reviews
MP Menupix
4.0/5
20 reviews

Rating distribution

5★
19
4★
26
3★
13
2★
9
1★
6
🚚 Delivery 🥡 Takeout 🍽️ Dine-in 🍺 Alcohol 🍹 Cocktails 🍷 Wine 📅 Reservations Wheelchair accessible Accessible restroom 😊 Casual 🛋️ Cozy 👥 Good for groups

💬 What people say

Pub 27 Party 18 Rye bread 18 Fish and chips 10 French onion soup 9 Toasted 9 Appetizer 7 Cole slaw 7

Contact Information

📞 Phone: +1 631-979-9073
📍 Address: 92 E Main St, Smithtown

🕐 Opening Hours

Closed Opens at 11:00 AM
Monday1 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Tuesday2 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Wednesday3 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Thursday4 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Friday5 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Saturday6 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Sunday7 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Google Reviews

4.4/5
★★★★
469 Google reviews
M

Milan Sharik

★★★★★ 5/5
GREAT PLACE EXCELLENT SERVICE RESTAURANT. ENJOY IT VERY WELL.
Google
C

Courtney Thompson

★★★★★ 5/5
A typical pub atmosphere. We got a nice corner spot by the window for my dad’s retirement dinner. The sausage soup and filet mignon looked delicious! I had the mozzarella chicken and I brought home plenty of leftovers. You of course need to have the pub cheese and toast. I’m so glad they put it out on the table! This restaurant has been a long time for my entire family.
Read more
Google
S

Sang Nguyen

★★★★★ 5/5
We could all order something because the menu was so extensive. It was good to learn that a standard hamburger weighed 1/2 lb. It came with Cole slaw, onion rings, and fries. Our waiter was helpful, and everyone appreciated the good-sized amounts of food.
Google
C

Cody Martinez

★★★★★ 5/5
For more than 10 years, our family has made this place a favorite. The cuisine is consistently excellent, and the wait staff is always friendly and accommodating.
Google
S

Sharon

★★★★★ 5/5
Went on a dinner date with my husband. Peter, our waiter, was so sweet and the food was delicious. The fish and chips had a perfect crisp. The lobster bisque soup had a yummy spicy taste and my husbands onion sandwich dip was on point. The chicken wings were also finger licking delicious. Oh and my Bikini Martini rocked! Can’t wait to come back 👍🏻
Read more
Google
C

Charles Augusto

★★★★★ 5/5
It's excellent! This was a very wonderful surprise, and I can't praise this place enough. Why are you still reading this when you can give it a 5 out of 10 and try it for yourself right away?
Google
H

holly murtha

★★★★★ 5/5
French onion is 5 stars. The rye and cheddar ap is fabulous. I didn’t take pic of the dinners because they were amazing! Fish and chips and the chicken saltimbucco was fabulous! Will definitely be back!
Google
D

Dave Black

★★★★★ 5/5
I've just had the first of what I am now sure will be many meals at this restaurant. A bar and restaurant, we were sat at a booth on the bar side which was a little noisy but a Friday night at a bar what could be expected. We decided to try this restaurant tonight because the menu looked good. I can honestly say that this was the first meal thay I have had in a long while that legitimately had me say "wow". Every item of food from the lettuce and pickles that accompanied my burger to the burger itself and the appetizers was absolutely incredible. Not good. Not great. INCREDIBLE. My wife and I started with splitting the mushroom cap appetizer and the French Onion Soup. My wife, who is a big fan of stuffed mushrooms, took the first bite. She commented that they were the best she had ever had, and I heartily agree. Also, I have never cared for French Onion Soup. I ate probably more than my fair share of the soup here. It was the first time I have ever enjoyed French Onion Soup and it was perfect. I had the Poutine Burger and my wife had the Lobster Roll off of the weekly specials menu, both of whoch were, again, EXCEPTIONAL. The food was literally a 10 out of 10. And the wait staff was excellent as well. I wish to also compliment specifically the gentleman that was the waiters assistant/barback/busboy unsure of his title but his attitude was warm, positive, and infectious. He was a pleasure every time he came to our table, as was the waiter, who kept us in Soda and napkins without us even having to ask. This was a really pleasant suprise and I can not recommend this establishment more. 5 thumbs up, 10 out of 10, why are you still reading this go and try it for yourself right now!
Read more
Google
R

Richard Dorfman

★★★★★ 5/5
We were a party of 4 for lunch. No wait for a table though the restaurant began to fill up. The menu was vast so we all found something to try. It was nice to see that a regular burger was 1/2 lb. and was served with fries, onion rings and Cole slaw. Our waiter was attentive though he did forget a couple of items. Food portions were good and everyone enjoyed. There were no games for paying with a credit card. I'm sure we wouldn't hesitate to dine here again.
Read more
Google
C

Craig Fish

★★★★★ 5/5
We were just looking for cocktails (2 people) and a burger, not gourmet, so a friend suggested Old Street. Ample parking is a plus and we walked in and sat at the bar which is where you land when you first enter. This was a slow time, so we can't comment on service when it is busy. Christina was behind the bar and provided pleasant assistance. The slightly worn, old school vibe of the place was comfortable for us. We had a straight burger platter which was huge and it came with fries, Cole slaw and pickles, and our other order was for a liverwurst & onions on rye that was a special, served with potato salad (great), slaw and pickles. The dishes were delicious, well prepared and abundant. A couple of pumpkin martinis and an IPA finished us off with no hope of room for desert. This is now on our list of places to revisit.
Read more
Google
Help improve this page:
← Back to all restaurants in Smithtown

🍽️ Suggest a dish

⚠️ Report error

🚫 Report closed

Do you confirm that Old Street Pub has permanently closed?