Best Restaurants in Shirley

⭐ Top

★ 99 /100

View →

Wade Lucas Farms

Healthy

💬 102 reviews

📍 8246 Highway 16 E

⭐ Top

★ 94 /100

View →

Strathmore Bagels

Cafe

💬 360 reviews

📍 999 Montauk Hwy Unit 8

🍴

⭐ Top

★ 94 /100

View →

Ralph's Italian Ices

💬 181 reviews

📍 990 Montauk Hwy

⭐ Top

★ 93 /100

View →

Citi Island Seafood

Seafood

💬 33 reviews

📍 60 Northern Blvd Ste 8

🍴

⭐ Top

★ 92 /100

View →

Sunshine Deli

💬 80 reviews

📍 525 Neighborhood Rd

📋 Menu ⭐ Top

★ 90 /100

View →

Giacalone Pork Pasta Deli

Italian Deli

💬 176 reviews

📍 464 William Floyd Pkwy

★ 90 /100

View →

Tend Coffee

Cafe

💬 844 reviews

📍 924 Montauk Hwy

★ 89 /100

View →

Okeno Sushi

Japanese Sushi Asian

💬 864 reviews

📍 451 Glen Dr

★ 88 /100

View →

Trelawny's Restaurant

Caribbean

💬 156 reviews

📍 921 Montauk Hwy

🍴

★ 88 /100

View →

Weenies On Wheels

💬 42 reviews

📍 1029 William Floyd Pkwy

📋 Menu

★ 85 /100

View →

The Bull Run Restaurant

American Bar

💬 1432 reviews

📍 215 Great Rd

★ 85 /100

View →

Village Pizza

Pizza

💬 250 reviews

📍 1 Front St

★ 85 /100

View →

The Mona Lisa

American

💬 15 reviews

📍 500 Highway 9 E

★ 85 /100

View →

New Oriental Kitchen

Asian

💬 330 reviews

📍 451 Glen Dr

📋 Menu

★ 85 /100

View →

Savanora's Pizzeria

Pizza

💬 160 reviews

📍 999 Montauk Hwy Unit 22

★ 84 /100

View →

Beach Hut At Smith Point

American Bar Seafood

💬 1378 reviews

📍 William Floyd Parkway

★ 84 /100

View →

Ramsey Pizza And Cafe

💬 125 reviews

📍 45 Ramsey Rd

📋 Menu

★ 83 /100

View →

Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen

💬 1816 reviews

📍 17 Mcgraw Street

🍴

★ 83 /100

View →

Gerardo's Pizza & Pasta

💬 1071 reviews

📍 800 Montauk Hwy

📋 Menu

★ 83 /100

View →

Airport Diner Shirley

Diner American

💬 190 reviews

📍 108 Lancaster Rd