Best bagels on LBI!!! Fresh, crisp and often warm and right out of the oven. Management changed prior to 2023 but service has gotten even better plus their bagels have gotten larger!
Great breakfast sandwiches & muffins too.
This place is busy and tasty! Yum! Bagels are top notch. Service can be a little slow late morning, so get there early!
Stopped in on a Saturday morning and the line was crazy long. I did wait for a good 15 minutes or more, but it was so worth it. Bagels were still warm from the oven. A perfect light and crispy crust with a soft doughy interior. Got a bacon egg and cheese as well. There were 2 slices of cheese, which personally for me changes the balance, and I wish I had known, I would have asked for only one slice. But that's such a random criticism it almost doesn't even matter, some people probably love extra cheese. I would absolutely recommend this place, and I will surely be back.
Quick service and friendly staff despite being a super busy spot. Iced coffee and blueberry muffin were delish!
Seriously the best bagels I have had in my life. Rivals any bagel I have had in NYC, which is not easy to say. Plus it's fun to see the huge bagel machine and the workers are so friendly. Can't wait to visit again when I am back in LBI.
So happy to have been able to meet the new owner and get my favorite French toast bagels to go for my trip home today! The staff is all so nice and helpful, it’s so nice to see familiar faces over the years. The owner could not have been any nicer and accommodating. I can also tell the employees are much more comfortable these days. The line seems long but it flows seamlessly. The bagels are so delicious and super fresh! The coffee is really good and they have all the dairy alternatives :) bageleddies has been a family staple my whole life and I am thrilled to see it still thriving and doing so well under the new ownership!!! We can’t wait to be back for our 2024 bageleddies breakfasts already!
Fantastic place. They have a wide variety of bagels, sandwiches, pastries/baked goods to choose from. I talked to the owners a bit (family owned) and they seems very nice too - which counts. I have a few bagels and egg sandwiches and they were great. I don't think they have seating there and they only take cash. However, they do have an ATM inside.
Update. Went here a few more times and still extremely happy with the food and service. Meet the owners (Donna and Tommy) and had a couple nice conversations with them.
Update 6/25/18: New location across the street. Bigger with outdoor seating and some yard games. Air conditioning now too!
Love this place. Usually crowded, and rightfully so because they have great bagels, sandwiches, pastries, and coffee! Me and my family stay in a beach house in close walking distance and I find myself going here every morning for breakfast while I'm visiting. Highly recommend
I tried a few different bagel flavors at Bageleddi's during my visit, which were all superb, but I have to say the French Toast bagel is easily the BEST bagel I've ever had. Next time I find myself in LBI I will be coming back :) Wonderful service as well, everyone is so friendly. Thank you!!!!
New York style bagels, large selection were warm and toasty. Rainbow bagels were delicious and really pretty.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Ship Bottom
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes