Sluurpy
Reset

There are 2 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Pasta in Shelter Island Heights

There are 2 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Isola
83/100 (200 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Pizza
Italian
Italian
Vegan Options
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegan Options
Dinner
Pesto
Eggplant
Pasta
Salad
Pizza
Italian
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Dinner
Mid-range
"An amazing, delicious birthday dinner with great staff and great service! I couldn’t have asked for anything more...Isola never..."
Shelby Mundy
"Brad has done a brilliant job, Jordan is THE server-extraordinaire, and Dancing Jenna & Mike on bar top it off... it’s the perfect food and drink..."
Christopher Edgar
"Great food, great ambiance, the entire staff and the owner make it my go to restaurant. Prices for the specials are unbeatable. I could eat there..."
Kiki Boucher
"Great food and great service! Very attentive staff without being..."
Steve Landau
"The cocktails are fantastic, as are the staff and the food is incredible. The chicken parmigiana is TDF. Love it here..."
Sarah-Jayne Keeton
"Pizza was excellent! Our server was very knowledgeable and friendly. Great experience! Can't wait to go..."
Judy Meringer
"What an amazing time we had!!! Brad and Jenna are the..."
Karen Ellis Varsano
"Staff is fantastic. Food is amazing. Love the atmosphere and decor. One of our favorite places to..."
Sam Alviti
"Enjoyed Isola last night. Black Bass was amazing along with the Buratta, Frito Mista and Pasta. Service was excellent and such a great setting. Best..."
Bryan J. Carey
"Lovely little Italian place, good food, friendly service, prices no less but no more than you'd expect for one of the roughly two places to dine on a..."
David Chess
"Had the pleasure of my wife and I returning to one of our Islands restaurants, Isola last night and was really pleased. It’s nice to begin..."
Don DeVries
"Visited this fun little place off season and was delighted to find live music (from local artist Sarah). We didn't make reservations prior and had to..."
meera dave
"Great atmosphere on the front porch and nice drinks. Good food with friendly service. Delicious risotto balls and burgers. Stays open a bit later..."
Ursula V
"Some of the best wings I have ever had. The portions are great and the rest of menu looks fantastic. The eggplant parm was delicious and..."
Danny Betanzos
"Highly recommend. You'll wait a bit, but they make up for it being the nicest people. The food is..."
Chuck Prato
"Went without a reservation. They made sure I had a good table letting me know when the reserved table time was. Took very good care of me. Food was..."
gail busch
"We order pizza and pasta and both were solid good. The wine list is also comprehensive and with variety. We truly enjoyed our..."
Julia C
"We stopped in for dinner on the bar side during the off season with live Saturday night music. The music was awesome, 5-stars to him..."
Joe Straub
"Comfortable and flavorful and open on a Thursday night after labor day. Even the crust of the pizza was deliciously seasoned. Attention to detail..."
Lori Quinn (Lqbesty)
"Cacio de Pepe!!! So so good.... beautiful setting, friendly people, great service and most importantly, the food is..."
Kym Dennis
"My wife and I originally picked this restaurant because it was the only place still open at 9 p.m. We were seated on the front porch, and we had the..."
remotelyviewed
"Pleasantly surprised by this gem. In the midst of COVID insanity, we were warmly welcomed to this lovely Italian restaurant. We had outdoor..."
Marie Raptis
"Really nice place and very accommodating as we have an old pup that comes with us. Wines very good and food is authentic..."
Lee
Sunset Beach
76/100 (702 ratings)
Restaurants
Seafood
Seafood
American
French
French
American
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Late Night
Brunch
Drinks
Pasta
Crispy Veal Milanese
Salad
Cosi's Casareccia
Sunset Fries with Cheese
Crab
Natural Light
Peeko Oysters
Mussels
Sunset Tuna Tartare
Tuna
Grilled Lamb on the Rack
Bloody Mary
Sangria Bianca
Octopus
Surf and Turf
Fried Artichokes
Kale Salad
Pesto
Burger
Vodka Cranberry Juice
Amalfi Spritz
Rigatoni
Grilled Branzino
prosecco
Charred & Yummy Sweet Potato
Shrimp
Creamy Burrata
Hot Mussels
Sit down
American
French
Seafood
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Waterfront
Breakfast
Dinner
Late Night
Lunch
Drinks
Brunch
Fine Dining
"This magical Hamptons experience never fails to impress my houseguests. Few outdoor spots out east can provide the perfect mix of gorgeous beach,..."
Thuyen Nguyen
"Best place for lunch - week days! The food staff vibe is something no place has ! One of a kind experience. Love this place..."
Shawn Kelley
"Great spot and great food!!! Very dog friendly too! A great place to go and highly recommended. The staff there is..."
Regan Tip
"Best view and beach in town. Great service (look for Isabella, Victor and Debra) and good amenities. Explore the island on bikes then be back for..."
Shanna Marie
"A best place to be on Sunday. It reminds me of French Riviera : cool vibe and nice..."
Annie Lopez
"Great spot and the staff is what makes this place special. I came for a day, stayed for a..."
Stephen Powell
"Great wine, great food, great service. Like being in St.Trop. Best arriving by boat. Gorgeous sunsets of course. Best for lunch,or at..."
Jeanne Arnold
"Very beautiful sunset, interesting and unusual bar and restaurant with fun things for kids (games, ice cream) and good food and..."
Marjorie Greenberg
"Loved everything about Sunset Beach, the location provides the most beautiful sunset. A perfect place to hang with family and friends for dinner or..."
Maria Graci Kelly
"Love this place! The restaurant is amazing ❤️ The food the vives the drinks!!! But the best is the sunset 🌅 love it..."
Carolina Trujillo
"Not sure if there’s any sexier place on LI! It feels as you are out of this..."
Ana Cristina Dezso
"Great vibe, good food, Monica is the best waitress..."
Katina Gounaris Karagounis
"Beautiful setting, delicious food, and lovely staff! What's not to..."
Glenn Navia
"Amazing! Favorite place to watch the sun set. Food is great. Staff is..."
Cindy Spivack Jacobs
"Sunset beatch es excelente tranquilo sin molestias y muy buen sitio para acampar en la..."
Charlie ML
"Exquisite French chef. Caring, professional staff and gorgeous views. Paradise! I never want to..."
Loraine Shields
"Despite not making reservations in July, I was seated very quickly. Next time ill make sure to make reservations so I can sit on the rooftop. The..."
Evelin
"Had lunch there today and the place is pretty cool; amazing water views, great food and drinks. Our servers deserve special recognition. Jonathan R..."
Charles Sankowich
"Sunset Beach is a Shelter Island institution. Always a great time. French fries and frosé are a hit, beach scenery is lovely, and the music is top..."
Owen Hayes
"My happy place! Need I say more. The food, ambiance and if you like chase sunsets then you’re at the right..."
Stephane Guerrier
"There is no other place quiet like Sunset. We’ve stayed here, we drink & eat here annually and watch the sunset. Staff is friendly, drinks are..."
Vanessa Cuccurullo
"Amazing place i feel like i am in Europe, super cool sandy beach and tasty food and friday nights all full...."
mehmet pala
"If you want drinks with an amazing sunset with incredible people watching, then this is a great spot. You will pay more for that drink but it's..."
Adam Bundy
"Had a birthday dinner at the restaurant. It was delicious and great views. The service was also on..."
Donna Handler
"Stopped by the beach bar restaurant again on the boat (Sunday June 18, 2023) - always great! Terrific place for drinks in the late afternoon and..."
mybeneteau brian
"We come every year on several occasions each year. Every year you have people who show up with no reservations trying to eat at the restaurants whose..."
Roy P
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use