I really wanted to eat pizza and since I never tasted Papa John's Pizza, I wanted to give it a try. I ordered online for pickup. My online ordering experience was excellent, there was even a deal : a large pizza with two toppings and brownies for 15$ ( without taxes ) , so I took it. The pizza was ready after 25 mins exactly the time that they set. They sent me a text message as soon as it was done and I went to pick up. Back home, I wasn't disappointed at all while eating the pizza. It was delicious! The garlic sauce given with the pizza was so tasty and the brownies was divine. Overall I really enjoyed and I recommend it to each and every person who want to eat a great pizza.
Everything was excellent. My wings had nuff buffalo sauce and my pizza was delish!!!!!
Really good more accesible they close 3 am so I like more lol
I went there just now and the food was so good yummy I would def go back and get what I got today
Raj just served Nancy once again, with the most friendly attitude. He and his staff are very patient with explanations of their pies. My daughter and I enjoyed the piazza last time and that is why I returned again. I just hope they don’t close early again, bc it forced me to go to another place late at night and that piazza tasted like cardboard and no way measured up to this Pappa Johns. Koodles to Raj and his staff. -Nancy
The pizzas were the bomb!!!! Awesome and quick service. I'm a regular. ❤️
I received a flyer with specials. I called to order several. It did take a while to get the order through I don't believe I was speaking to someone from my store. There was an echo. I received a call back from the store to confirm the order and the time which was only 15-20 minutes for 8 items including 3 pies! That was very impressive! So was the food! First time ordering the papadias, delicious! I will definitely order again!
Highly recommend this location. The new owners are so nice. They really care about all their customers, and they never fail at making amazing pizzas. Delivery service is very timely and quick. The workers are very kind, everyone who works there is very friendly.
This Papa Johns location has amazing customer service and even better food. They have the option for Halal which is great and they have a wide variety of options to choose from! Delivery is always fast and easy and I would DEFIANTLY recommend this to anyone who wants to eat good!
I've ordered many times from this place over the past 6-7 years and never had any problems. Most of the time I've had the pizza delivered and added tip to the credit card (typically 15-18% and then more recently in the past 2-3 years 20-22%) and never had any problems with the delivery person having any issues. Heck - in one case we even had a free pizza delivered! We felt really bad about that one so we tipped generously (total charge was $1.50 delivery charge, so a 20% tip would've only been $0.30). I usually order three mediums with two different half toppings on each, and they've never messed it up. I'm not sure why all the reviews are so negative on here, but I felt I had to write my experiences to balance things out. I would definitely continue to order from them and recommend them to my friends. I'm not an employee or related in any way to Papa Johns.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Selden
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes