I've been working my way through the menu and so far, the pizza, meatball sub, wings, and calzones are top quality and rivals the best Highlands County has to offer. I have to rate all three menu items at a 10 --- there is no need for improvement.
Jan Gooch Ames Gaughan
+5
Cold Tomato Pie from Palmano's Pizzeria! We are from WNY (the Niagara/Buffalo area) and this pizza is called Old Fashioned Pizza ... it originated in 1917 at Trusello's bakery in Niagara Falls at the City Market. Their pizza came in 1/2 tray or tray. Palmano's Tomato Pie tastes close to the way Trusello made it. You eat it room temperature (not refrigerated and not hot). It only has sauce and shake on parmesan cheese, La Segunda Bakery in Ybor City, Tampa makes a similar cold pizza that is also delicious - called Scachatta Thank you Palmano's Pizza for bringing a taste of home to Florida! We love your Tomato Pie!
So glad we tried this place! Amazing fluffy crust, thin pizza with delicious ingredients and juicy wings! Will definitely order again
We order delivery and our orders always take forever. We live less than a mile from then and they always take over an hour. Even told me one time they were waiting for the bad storm to get over and it wasn't even raining any more.. i would know because like I said we are just down the road from them. And never get the extra extra mushroom on the pizza when ordered!!! I guess they are always busy and very acceptable because their food is good.. but can we get what we ordered? "Alex "a regular..
Pizza is pretty good. My son completely approved the flavor. (He’s the pizza enthusiast in the family 😆)
Dough was soft, fresh, no over cooked, maybe even a bit on the sweet side. Mozzarella was tasty. Their pizza sauce is good. Totally recommend.
We have found our Pizza Place! We are from NY and this is pretty close! Coming all the way from Indian Lake Estates, worth the windshield time.
I’ve been there twice now since moving here (both times pick-up for Lunch). I got very good pizza - hot, cooked properly, and tasty. I think it’s officially my favorite pizzeria in Sebring / Avon Park, so I’ll be a regular customer. I need to try more menu items.
1st Time we've tried this place. OMG not only was the pizza Amazing. We got the lg it is huge.We'll be eating leftovers for awhile. Im good with that!!
I had placed a few orders . Always bring it in time to my shop H&S truck repair shop. Best pizza in town , always taste delicious
Wow I am impressed about this place.. Excellent tasting great 18 "pizzas in the area.. 5 minutes from home enjoying it And loving it n highly recommend 1000 and more percentages!!!😋🤤🤤🤤🤤🤤😋 supplies meet demands and they are charging a little bit more now 😮💨 oh well 🤷🏽♀️🤦🏽♀️.
I could write a book about how great this review could be but I'll get straight to the pepperonis 😎 The food is amazing and fresh, the customer service was wholesome and top notch, and we discovered that they deliver! Even to the track 💪 Go order a pizza and some wings. Pssst... they even have white sauce for your pizza 🍕
The best pizza in town. Garlic knots to die for. The Stromboli is so good. Reasonable prices, too..
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Sebring
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes