The Gator Shack
4651 US Highway 98 - Sebring
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#18 of 89 restaurants in Sebring
Updated on
€€
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
65/100
Data Completeness
72/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🌳
Outdoor seating
🥡
Takeout
🍽️
Dine-in
🚚
Delivery
🍺
Alcohol
🍹
Cocktails
🍷
Wine
📅
Reservations
♿
Wheelchair accessible
♿
Accessible restroom
😊
Casual
🛋️
Cozy
👥
Good for groups
📊 Popular Times
Not busy
Moderate
Very busy
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
1,121
Google reviews
My sister and I met up there to celebrate our Christmas together. My sister lives in Sebring and I live in Port St Lucie. My sister has eaten there before for many years, first time I was there. To start I got the eggnog Martini they advertised. It was yummy- nice presentation I love the wafer stick- order it with the whipped vanilla vodka! We had the Mushroom and Fish Bites appetizers- delicious! I then had a chocolate martini that was great as well! Our waitress was Bailey and she was wonderful- we even moved out to the patio- I know it's a pain when people move from tables as I'm a server myself- but she was great with it and even offered to help move our stuff. Bailey's shift was ending and we were still there and we had the next server whose name was Bailey as well. Two Bailey's how fun- must be a real blast when they're both on the same shift! Anyway, we ordered dinner and more drinks with the second Bailey. My sister had the Fish dinner and I had the Ribeye 12oz.dinner- our sides were the mac and cheese oh so yummy my sister got coleslaw and I got the hand cut fries and we both had salad. I was surprised it came with salad after two sides- most places don't - salad is always extra- nice- good value. Everything was very tasty.Before we ordered dinner we met the lunch chef and his sidekick- sorry guys forgot your names! We had some questions about the food and they answered it all - fun guys. We had an excellent time!!! The only thing I can say is I'm a Wine Drinker-it would be nice to have some decent Wines By The Glass- where I work we serve Sycamore Lane as the house wine and I hate it- sorry I drank for taste! They do offer nicer wines -Oyster Bay, but it's only by the bottle. Well of course be dropping by again sometime down the road. Friendly atmosphere, not fancy, but that's the way we like it - good food , good people- memorable time. I highly recommend dropping by if you're in the area.
Read more
Google
It's a popular place with the locals. The staff back each other up, so even if it's busy, which it gets often during meal time, you don't need anything for long. The owner checked in with us while we were there. There's something for just about everyone on the menu, and being a bar, there's much to choose from. The food was tasty and timely. There's many different types of seating. You get the feeling that the staff really makes the atmosphere enjoyable. We had a great time and would go back again.
Read more
Google
Absolutely delicious! We drove by here so many times and decided to give it a try. 10/10 amazing. Very chill environment, the waitress/bartender was an absolute sweetheart and the food was phenomenal. I definitely recommend The Larry! And if you like chicken gizzards, they are lightly breaded and delicious. We will now make this restaurant a habit ❤ Totally looking forward to trying more menu items 😍
Read more
Google
Stopped in on our bikes for some lunch. We've passed it many times and decided to stop in today.
Friendly folks and good atmosphere. The Cheeseburgers were awesome and the fries were great. Wonderful service made it a great experience. We'll definitely be back!
Google
Found ourselves in Lorida, Fl and stopped for lunch. Service was great and personable (thanks Judy) and the good hit the spot after a hike. If I am ever out this way again I will definitely make it a point to grab some delicious food.
Google
Haley our waitress was beyond helpful. Great smile and always checked in on us. We met the owner and he came over and introduced himself. And the menu was full of interesting things to eat. My friend Claire tried gator bites for the first time.!
Google
First time I went and love the place and food. Familiar atmosphere with kind waitresses! The only thing I was a little sad was with the meat, I ask well well done and the meat wasn't well done, was very close, just need a little more but it was good.
Google
I’ve heard so many people talk about this place, and now I know why! Super cool place to eat at! It looks great, food and drinks are awesome! The gator bites were the best I’ve had in a while.
Google
Been here several times The service and food are constantly great. Steak nights on Friday and Saturday are perfectly cooked if you are a steak connoisseur you get to select the steak of your choice from the cart. Not much you can go wrong with here on the menu. It's divey dining at its best don't pass this place bye!
Read more
Google
Great mom n pop spot, good food, great service, ice cold beer served in chilled mugs. Friendly staff, Ashley and Tory behind the bar are great! Will definitely be back.
Update, went back for dinner. I had the ribeye steak, baked potato, and onion rings. Every bit of it was excellent.
Google
Explore more in Sebring
Help improve this page: