Nicky's Pizzeria

Updating my review. Returned a few more times this past month since I last wrote and am happy to report the wait time issue has been fixed. Perhaps they found their groove? I'm not sure, but I am happy about it. Food has been consistently within time measurements. Super stoked since they're the only good pizza place anywhere along the Chatham Parkway stretch.

First I should say that I only give ratings for restaurants or businesses if i find something truly amazing or absolutely horrible. We went to this Italian restaurant to try a new place. We ordered the Mozzarella Sticks, and Garlic bread with cheese for an appetizer and thought they were pretty good. For our main course my wife ordered the Chicken Alfredo with Fettuccine pasta and I ordered the Chicken Parmigiana with Capellini pasta. My wife has a sensitive stomach when it comes to Alfredo sauce but she absolutely adored the sauce, hand made pasta and chicken that came in the dish. She said the sauce was made perfectly and wasn't to thick or to thin. They also gave a very good amount of the sauce with the dish. When I cut into my chicken parmigiana I was amazed to find that it was so moist that it almost melted in my mouth. It was perfectly cooked, amazingly seasoned, and had just the right amount of crunch to it. The home made Marinara sauce was amazing as well and there portion size to price is just amazing. We would definitely recommend Nicky's to anyone who wants great Italian food.

Personally, I enjoy Nicky's! The whole experience. I never have a problem with the customer service or my food. The cashier is always nice with a smile on her face. After I place my order I'm able to make my drink, and take a seat. When my food is ready they bring it to my table. Which is awesome!! It wasn't a long wait either.. Everyone there is really nice which is a plus! My food was amazing, and the customer service was awesome! I enjoy coming to Nicky's, and I'll continue to eat here. Thank you guys for the best experience every time I come. Keep up the awesome work y'all!! I give them 5 stars🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟!!

I work down the street and my team has occasionally ordered from here and the pies are always excellent. Variety of fresh toppings to choose from and a friendly staff to top it off. They have plenty of other items aside from pizza and everything is made fresh. The space is small, but it is very clean and organized.

this place is lovely! Their pizza is AMAZING and their chicken parm is to die for. I love coming here, and I love getting delivery too. I just moved in to a new apartment not too far away, so this is going to be my to-go place for Italian! It's cute and quaint, and their cheese cake looks really good too. Its so nice to know that everything here is home made as well. <3 So yummy!

As the first meal under the new ownership(but same awesome staff) I was again very satisfied. I had the tortellini alfredo that was so creamy and delicious. I also got to tastedrive one of the new items coming soon...homemade cheesecake. I was told that tonight's cheesecake isn't as big as the usual size she makes but it was definitely big on flavor. If you haven't been to Nicky's you're really missing out! This is another review of today's amazing meal. I am trying more and more items on the menu to give a broader perspective and tonight was another great meal. I tried the lasagna with added sausage(recommended by the owner to add a little extra flavor) and it was delicious! You can tell that it's homemade, the cheese is spectacular and the sausage really topped it off. I got a side of garlic knots which just added more flavor to the meal. I can't wait until next visit for my next new meal!

In a small strip mall. Pizza is thin crust and more Neapolitan style. Delicious cheese on the pizza. The menu has pizzas, pasta, hot and cold subs, wraps and other Italian dishes. We ordered a medium pizza, half margherita and half "special" which is pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, green peppers and onion. We also had salads. The salad was a good size for $4.00 and the homemade balsamic vinaigrette was delicious. We were very happy with the pizza.