Casantica Ristorante

Our food was delicious, not to mention the desserts (profiteroles and tiramisu) uhmmm 😋The only thing I didn't like was that the restaurant was a bit busy and there was actually only one waitress, which made everything more delayed, the owner didn't help much, Her stress level was very noticeable. I saw how she treated a table that demanded their bread basket, and with her little English she was very rude with them, also her screams in the kitchen could be heard outside, the waitress seemed more controlled and she dominated the restaurant in a better way, you cannot be the owner and treat your customers like that, you have to learn to control and hide stress, set an example for your waiters and always smile.

Rarely write reviews, but have to give praise to this top-notch family restraunt. Truly felt honored to be in a place that felt far from home yet familiar at the same time. Enjoyed some of best home made Italian dishes I've ever had - whole family was impressed! Will be telling as many people as possible to visit, and eagerly look forward to the next meal with you! From our family to yours, I truly thank you for the experience and many blessings to you and yours!

This Restaurant is the most nicest restaurant I’ve been to in Sarasota. The workers and owners are so accommodating and they make sure you are enjoying your dinner. Very beautiful and clean place. The food is to die for and the home made pasta is delicious.. thank you to Emelia and Roberto he’s an amazing Chef .

Have seen this place for years while visiting the Florida Studio Theater, as it is in close proximity. Finally made reservations and took the plunge. It is located inside a century-old house downtown Sarasota. Warmly greeted, we were seated a somewhat romantic table for two. Nestor was our server and he was terrific. We ordered lobster ravioli and pasta bolognase. Both dishes were simply "the best". Genuine Italian cuisine at it's finest. Certainly everyone has their own tastes, but we both agreed that this was the best ever. As snowbirds - we will be back again. Great wine choices and reasonably priced all the way around. Great Italian food!!!!!!!!!

What a gem! Although tucked away with construction all around, it is worth making your way through! Authentic Italian dining experience. We felt like we were in their home while they cooked dinner for us. Excellent, personal service, superb house wine, and every course complimented the last. It is a must if you are in Sarasota!