Sluurpy > Restaurants in Santa Cruz > The Penny Ice Creamery

The Penny Ice Creamery - Santa Cruz - Photo album

I was in town and wanting some really good ice cream. Saw this on the map and it was open and had good reviews so thought I'd check it out. I got the cardamom pistachio chocolate chip with half of dark chocolate sorbet with the marshmallow topping. I honestly didn't enjoy this place. The ice creams

Tasty ice cream however it was very soft. We’ve been here several times but this time the ice cream was very soft and partially melted already. It might be because the lid wasn’t closed but it was disappointing to have ice real that was already so soft. I’d come back if I happened to be next door bu

My urge to have some ice cream and my wife's craving for Marsh mellow made us end up at this place. The place was cozy and the staff was very friendly and comforting. They made it very easy for us to select exactly what we wanted. We both ended up with the burnt Marsh Mello topping which is definite

DEFINITELY get the marshmallow fluff!! The Penny Ice Creamery always has a handful of interesting new flavors and they are pretty much always excellent. Friendly staff too. Huge plus, it's open late! I have to go here every time I visit Santa Cruz.

Such a delight! I had the Tahitian Vanilla Bean with toasted marshmallow fluff — what an experience! Very friendly staff and excellent quality ice cream. A bit on the sugary/very sweet side, but it’s ice cream 😜🍦

Wonderful flavors, home-made ice cream with a definite dairy taste. The ice cream is over the top sweet. Less sugar would help the flavor come out more and help the ice cream go down. Just too much sugar.

Amazing homemade best in the area. Try with toasted marshmallows. Wny Penny Ice-cream? They used to sell ice cream for pennies long time ago.

This is the best vanilla ice cream I have ever had. I know it is basic but there is something so buttery good about the Tahini Vanilla Bean flavor. Some people may not like their more experimental flavors so I would stick to the vanilla. The marshmellow fluff is popular here for the pictures but I f