The best Restaurants in Rochester | Sluurpy updated in April

"There may not be a heaven in the sky, but a slice of cheesecake from Cheesy Eddie's is like heaven in your mouth. The service is always great,..."

Rocco Hagen

"I've enjoyed their carrot cake for years, but the past few years we have been trying different cheesecakes. I can not fathom how they make their..."

Lauren Adams

"We received two cheesecakes sent to us by some family members a couple of weeks ago. I’m not usually a fan of typical commercially baked..."

Nancie Zimmerman

"Cheesy Eddie’s cheesecake (plain) was the very best we have had in forever...."

Ken Miller

"They have the best cheesecake (my wife agrees). And they are opening a new..."

Abraham Long

"Their delicious carrot cake is like no other. I’ve tried other places like Wegmans or Cheesecake Factory and there is honestly no..."

Edward Antonio

"The best cheesecake & carrot cake in town. Great people that work there and always friendly & willing to help. Highly recommend to..."

Joe Decicca

"Best. Cake. Ever. Can't decide if I like the carrot cake or cheesecake better. So just get both. So delicious!!!!! Had my wedding cake from there..."

Lindsay Campbell Schiffman

"We have come from Buffalo to Cheesy Eddies at least once a year. Most amazing carrot cake, and great cheesecake..."

Nikia Glapa

"Best place for dessert! Try the Peanut Butter Blossom..."

Mary Bradley

"Awesome cupcakes & the best vanilla cheesecake..."

Maria Gnida

"The cheesecake is great and the customer service was even better! We loved the key lime..."

Maggie Rizzo

"Just left Cheesy Eddies with an Original Cheesecake (my fave) and a Carrot Cake cupcake. Such a great business, great Customer Service and delicious..."

Kathy Lutzken

"We're from Ohio. We visit relatives and friends and Cheesy Eddie's.Not necessarily in that..."

Pete Finta

"Not sure which is better, your chocolate cheesecake or your customer service - both are fantastic! (...apologies now for the lengthy review) From..."

Sara Cousins

"I was so impressed with the Customer Service my daughter & I received last Friday on our first ever visit to your shop! Your carrot cake is the best..."

Jo Ann Pilger VerHulst

"I recently moved here and found out they were doing this promotion where they are giving away free cheesecake! I came here to try them for the first..."

Chris Koontz

"I have tried two sugar-free cheesecakes from Cheesy Eddie’s: Marble and raspberry swirl. Both were delicious! I wish there would be more sugar-free..."

Olivia

"Open one hour later on Saturdays than the South Ave location. Large store, clean and well organized. There are a few stairs to get in, which should..."

Zsuzsanna Sziveri

"Great selection! Friendly staff! Their carrot cake is insane! Loved the sampler..."

jennifer white

"Thee best freaking cheesecake cupcakes in Rochester!!! Cheesy Eddie’s has 2 locations here but I want to review the Henrietta location because the..."

Tequila S.

"This was my first time at Cheesy Eddie’s (I’m from out of town). We ordered 5 cheesecakes for our wedding. The cheesecake was a hit and everyone..."

Kayla Pupio

"We went for the freebie on cheesecake day. Both flavors were delicious. I'm definitely going back for a full cheesecake soon. Problem is what..."

Renee Smith

"Oh my, their original cheesecake is definitely worth the trip! Well made, soft, creamy and decadent - it's no surprise that they had a queue! Nice..."

Suzanna Law

"Would highly recommend Cheesy Eddie's, perfect 5 star for customer service-Stephen helped me with my order. Aside from making my mini present..."

Esathena Nabata

"Literally my favorite cheesecake place ever! Staff is friendly with suggestions, lots of cute variety of other desserts too..."

Cecie Valleri

"Best cheese cake I have ever had. I have it sent to me in Florida and I purchase it when I’m..."

stephanie bartolotta

"Definitely not just your average cheesecake. This is how cheesecake is supposed to be. Well done. I will be..."

Steve Harris

"Wow! We preordered the Carrot Cake Cheesecake and it was ready at the time we scheduled to pick it up. The person at the counter was friendly and..."

Rodd Riesenberger

"Best cheesecake in Western NY. You won't find anyone best. Everything is fresh and staff is..."

Derek Beckwith

"This is what my friend Darryl had written on his belated birthday carrot cake. Impressive piping by Cheesy Eddie's in..."

Deana Matuch

"Visited the Friday morning before Christmas Sunday. The line was winding and snaking around about 15+ people deep and remained at this steady volume..."

John-David Rocha

"If you haven't tried Cheesey Eddie's, you've yet to have the best cheese/carrot cake there is! Best deserts..."

Jeff Ryan

"Clean, pristine with friendly service! I ordered/paid online and picked up the next day. Lots of wonderful choices. The carrot cake might be one of..."

Carin Fletcher

"The best cheesecake ever! We love the key lime, cherry cheesecake , Oreo, amaretto and of course the original is amazing. Had a chance to try their..."

Reset

There are 2062 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Restaurants in Rochester

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Rudi Braun

Cohen Sprague

Noah ronek

Wendy Yu

Lisa Lynn

Katherine Donohue

Ceren Jackson

Lexy McCauley

David Reagan

paulaschank

Chris Rockwell

George H Sweatt

Melissa Stio

Tammra Schiller

Matthew Sisson

Jherell D

christina guarin

Kevin Markman

Thomas Morgan

Kaeley McAdam

ElenaMarie Burns