Mr. Sam's Pizza Kitchen

We’ve been enjoying Grandpa Sam’s for 20 years and have never been disappointed. Truly a hidden gem of the Westside that rivals any traditional Italian cuisine in the Greater Rochester Area. Fresh ingredients, lovely atmosphere, and friendly service are staples of this intimate well-run restaurant. The expansion / renovation resolved the only issue they had ever experienced - not enough space to satisfy the demand.

Our first visit was for dinner on a Friday night. We had reservations and were seated immediately. Our server, Jill, was very friendly and informative. She explained the daily specials and got us started with drinks. Our soups were housemade, fresh and hot. My wife had Italian wedding soup and I had the seafood bisque, which was excellent, rich and chunky. Salad was served family style with a very nice house Italian dressing. Our entries were excellent. My wife had butternut ravioli and I had seafood fra diavalo, with shrimp, clams, scallops, mussels and calamari. Jill was attentive to our needs even as the entire dining room filled up and they had a private party going on as well. Highly recommended to us and we highly recommend to you. We will be back!

Definitely not a chain restaurant. Always ample portions and a great value for the money. The only minor inconvenience is not having a full liquor license and only beer and wine, but they do offer some cocktails, but the real reason is you come for the food. I would recommend reservations but with their new expanded room they have ample seating.

There will be no cocktails served here. However, they have a small selection of wine and beer available. Our dinners were excellent 👌 and quite expensive IMO. The looming waitresses were happy to take your jacket and oddly sat us one side of the restaurant whilst other side remained nearly empty. Spotless!! and very up to date (on the inside) is what you'll see when you arrive. Overall I give it a 3.5 . Would have been higher but a simple plate of spaghetti shouldn't cost 20$.

Danielle took great care of us last night. We chatted, laughed, and had a delicious meal! While pricey, it's worth it for quality, local food right in the village. Try the pomodoro sauce- you will NOT be disappointed! The homemade desserts are to die for! I tried a special Nutella mousse- it came in a champagne flute and was layers upon layers of chocolate goodness. (Dear owner, if you see this, PLEASE put it on the menu!!) The atmosphere is lovely. It was a Wednesday night, there were several tables, and all of us got the undivided attention that made everyone's experience enjoyable. The place is nice- not too fancy and WAYYYYY better than olive garden (though I'm guilty of enjoying their bread sticks once in a while). The bread with dipping oil here was delicious, soft, warm, fresh and with good REAL Italian olive oil. The dressing on the house salad (salad and bread come with every meal) was tangy and delicious! Overall, you have to check this place out at least once. It's not everyones cup of tea, but it sure was ours and we will be back again soon!