Review Mamma Lucia - Rochester

This restaurant is a hidden gem! I happened upon it by recommendation from a friend. It apparently has recently changed owners, and has taken on a fresh, new look inside. It was previously known for its amazing brunch, and so that tradition is being continued in addition to a new menu that offers much variety, and frankly a high level of quality no matter what you pick. (It's not an easy choice as everything looks really good.) So far I've had both the brunch and dinner several times; each time trying something different. If it's possible to make a plate of food with undivided love and attention, this is the real deal! The wait staff, as we learned, have at least a decade of experience behind them; very courteous and willing to please. (BTW, I saw a table of very rude customers near me the other day. They were constantly complaining after apparently arriving a whole hour late for their reservation, and after voicing displeasure with some chicken, for which they weren't even charged, ate the food anyway! I couldn't believe my eyes! One would think that if the food was not good enough, it would remain untouched. The waitress had the patience of a saint, and if anything, the other customers could clearly see the truth to the whole situation. I guess some folks just want extra attention and a free meal while integrity and basic kindness get left behind.) Also, there is a very good pianist that comes to play live music (varied genres but nothing deafening) on certain evenings. I fully support and recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for a quality meal at a bargain price, and one served by some very kind people!

My experience was excellent! Salmon and sides were delicious! Relaxing atmosphere with a pianist playing. I do and will recommend this restaurant to others. Thank-you I will be back.

They have the best food that I've eaten in such a long time! The place is beautiful and amazing and the owners are very lovely people. Thank you guys so much for the food, I will see you as soon as possible ❤️

Although Mamma Lucia has been known primarily for their fabulous brunch, we went to try out their cevapi. For those of you who may never have had them, if you like burgers, you will love these! Having lived in both Bosnia and Croatia for over a decade, I can attest to their authenticity. I actually preferred Mamma Lucia's bread (samun) over the original--it is homemade daily and you can tell. Excellent desserts--we had the baklava and our server actually gave me the last piece of their wonderful krempita (it was the special dessert from the previous day). On top of it all, the service was warm and genuine. We had a lovely time.

Amazing food. Italian food with the chefs very own Bosnian and German twist. Everything made in house. Will definitely be back.

We loved it here! The food was amazing from appetizers, entrees to the deserts. The staff was friendly. Congratulations Senada and Orhan. You have done a beautiful job. We will be back! ❤️

Great food choices and quality,owners and personal very friendly...definitely place to visit...

Wonderful food, wonderful staff and owners!!!!!! Especially bartender Faruk

Best New Year celebrations! Delicious food, fun music, helpful waiters, good company! Thank you Pehlivanovici!