Liz Bausch
What a gem! Delicious food, generous portions, unique dishes, wonderful folks, and excellent service that is so rare these days! We can't wait to go back!
mike cigan
This is my very first review. I couldn't let this gem of a restaurant go unnoticed. I ordered the haddock casino which was unbelievable. House salad/ dressing was also very good. Big portions and fair prices. Wish I could take this restaurant back home to Indiana with me. Wouldn't hesitate to go back.
Sue Zepp
We went there with a group of four good friends last night. Most had the seafood platter that was absolutely fabulous. Food was 5 star. Our server was the best. The only complaint we have to make is there were two tables of 4 that were very disrespectful, screaming loudly and making everyone else in the restaurant feel uncomfortable. The last straw was when they started slamming their glasses on the table and broke them, cheering loudly. It got kind of scary being in that atmosphere. Our waitress kept apologizing to us for their behavior. The owner was there and should have thrown them out but didn't. I understand they are regular customers and the restaurant is small and could be loud but that shouldn't condone their behavior. We told the owner we wouldn't come back if he allowed people to behave like that. It wasn't a nice dining experience and I know some of the other diners felt the same way. If you were one of these disruptive, disrespectful people, please stay home next time and let other people enjoy themselves.
stacy avangelista
We have been coming here for awhile. Hilton has a LOT of restaurants all with wood fired pizzas, bar food etc. Forest Hill is beyond. Amazing diverse menu, EXCELLENT proportions, NOT the usual mundane. Jaime the server can handle the whole dining room blind folded, and Doug the bartender will make you feel like your on Cheers. Complete with an actual FULL pour on a glass of wine. We LOVE it here and are always full and satisfied. Only downfall, no reservations on Fridays so get there early!!!!
Sean Hanley
First time there. Food was excellent, service was great. Good size menu. Barmaid was very professional and personal. Portions are good size, prices reasonable. Will be stopping in there again for sure. Very impressive.
Deb
Excellent! First time at establishment, honestly never heard of. It's a hidden gem. The food was SO good. The blue cheese dressing was delicious, thick chunky, and pair perfectly with salad. Fried calamari was really good. The broiled seafood platter was cooked perfectly and included haddock, stuffed shrimp, scallops, and clams casino. The stuffing on the shrimp was so unique and yummy. Others in party enjoyed their dishes too. The restaurant is pretty small and filled up fast. Will definitely be back, so good!!
Sarah Armoto
The restaurant is on the small side so our group of 6 were all squeezed around a table best suited for 4. Both of the people who ordered steak were disappointed but enjoyed everything else they ordered. Everyone else was happy with their orders.
1twothelmalou
Good service, good selection of food. Very noisy if sitting toward bar side . Hard to have a conversation. Next time will request different area.
Dan Morris
The food was amazing! The chicken parmigiana was delicious! Don’t even get me started on the two sides. Hands down the BEST corn I have ever had at a restaurant! Definitely the perfect spot to hit after a nice day at Niagara Falls!
Chester Rinaudo
Excellent food, service
Price is right, and the portions....
Fugetabouit
Angelo Mazzucco
Haven't been here in 20 years or more. Still very good food with huge portions. A regular dinner you can share with ease. If you get a fish fry I would get 1 per person. Good service with a decent price I will return!
Jeff Williams
I've been wanting to try this place for the past couple of years and I finally did tonight. It was the best meal I've had out in a long time. Everything was delicious and they give you large portions. I will definitely be back soon!
Nite Owl
Charming intimate atmosphere almost on the lake. Tasty entrees good selection and large portions. Shrimp cocktail was disappointing. Undercooked and mushy for $20. Don't order!! Bar area cozy....good place to wait for your table. Reservations a must for the dinner hours. Seems to be a strong local clientele that frequents this establishment. Would have got 5 stars if not for the shrimp cocktail.
Elizabeth Thelen
Waitress funny and nice, food was amazing!
Tracy Nowack
Love eating here when I'm in town. Delicious, creative dishes packed with so much flavor and fresh ingredients. Always excellent service and attention to detail. We didn't have reservations but luckily got it in right when they opened. The place filled up fast.
Steve Passarell
Have been coming here for years. It is a hidden gem to put it lightly. My wife and I have never had a bad meal. We frequently bring friends for the first time and they are always happy with pricing, selection and quality of food. Jeanine and Jamie are 2 of the best servers around and make everyone comfortable. If you haven't been there you really need to get there. You will not be disappointed.
Great Lakes Classic Cars
Great establishment! Mike and staff go above and beyond to welcome and provide quality food and service for everyone.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes