I've had Amico's all of 4 times now. Two of which were people bringing the pizza into work or a party, and we loved those pies.
Both those times were great. Since they don't deliver out to our part of West Irondequoit, we stopped here twice now on our own.
The first time we just did a normal peppe
Outside of the owner (Dave Amico) being salt of the earth, and his family/staff being so friendly and polite, it’s hands down the best pizza in the city!! I don’t even know one that’s even close. The crust is to die for and the toppings and homemade sauce just have so much flavor. In a pinch when we
Had high hopes for the pizza but unfortunately it did not live up to it. It was not a bad pizza but it was very greasy, lacked a lot of flavor, and the crust was a bit soggy. On the other hand the Italian sausage was great and the cheese was fantastic.
Best pizza in town. Forget the fuss, set aside the gimmicks. Turns out that what makes great pizza is not the material your oven is made from, or whether it burns wood, coal or gas. Great pizza comes from skilled hands and great ingredients, and Amico’s has that in abundance. It’s great pizza, perfe
I just tried Amico's for the first time Saturday, and they were great! Super nice and clear over the phone, food made as ordered and delivered quick. What else could you ask for? It was $46 for a medium with 2 toppings on half, and 15 wings with some extra bleu cheese delivered [more after for tip,
Bianco: Fresh chopped garlic & olive oil topped with tomatoes onions fresh basil and Pecorino-Romano, mozzarella and ricotta cheeses with added cherry peppers.
The #1 was excellent-- very unique pizza that is more sauce than cheese. I'll be back!
Great pizza, 2 topping large for $23. I forgot to put 2 blue cheeses on my online order, and so I tried to pay for them, and the young lady said don't worry about it. That was the most impressive part! Thank you! 4 outta 5 stars, cause it coulda used a little more sauce, but great place! Cheers!
We've been customers for about 10 years. Hands down the best breakfast pizza in the city! I also love their NYC style thin crust, the homemade ingredients, and how accommodating the staff has been to meet complicated orders.
SO much oil in their pizza... but it's flavorful.. i hope they use healthy oil in this..
We had a pepperoni pizza - which was solid. The best part was chatting with Dave and his son's while we waited for the pizza to cook. After 15 minutes, it felt like we'd known them forever and were friends. Skip the chain pizza places ... This is where you wanna go.
Some of the best pizza I’ve had in the city. Shines far above chains and trendy build-your-own places. Amicos is one of our go tos now, right up there with pudgies and delindas. Fantastic
Great hand-tossed pizza. A staple in Irondequoit for decades and they don't disappoint. The ingredients are fresh and the customer service is great. Please treat them well, they work hard. Btw, the homemade chocolate chip cookies are perfect.
They accommodated me on a complicated order for delivery
My first order from here, had a small pizza and 5 wings with garlic sauce. The wings were delicious, crispy and garlicy. The pizza was great. The dough had a slightly sweet taste, the sauce and toppings were excellent. I've recently moved into this area and have been looking for a great pizza place.
This was our first time ordering and we were not disappointed. It was the best pizza we have tasted in a long time. Not only that your prices are very family friendly.
Finally found a great place. Pizza is fantastic. AND Wings are fantastic. Strongly recommend.
Was referred by a customer from webster.
I live in walworth, and took the dare.
Well worth my drive. The pizza is delish!
Can't wait to try the wings!
Bravo!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes