Captain Jim's Fish Market

I had an amazing first-time visit to this store. The experience was absolutely perfect. I can confidently say that the fish and chips served here are the best I've ever had. The taste is incredibly authentic and the flavors are absolutely delicious. The owner of the store is extremely enthusiastic, which adds to the overall charm of the place. I strongly believe that this shop deserves a recommendation from me to everyone I know!

Hi to Jim's staff and prospective customers Please take my review from 3 years ago with "a grain of salt" as the expression goes. That review was in the middle of the pandemic and staff shortages. I haven't been there in years since we've relocated to Virginia but I still rate Jim's as the best fish fry in Rochester by far, and it appears other reviewers since my old entry still do too. From 2020: A direct suggestion to the owner: Hi this seems like the best way to give you feedback since it looks like you read the reviews. Yesterday, 8/28, I had my first bad experience. While you were short staffed, for which I forgive you, your phone seemed like it eas off the hook for about an hour at 5-6 pm. I never got to order, visited to try to order in person and walked away. Why not add on-line ordering? It would free up one of your people to fill orders. We,ve been customers for years, love your food and people. Just trying to hell. I,ll be back again tonight to try again. Best Regards

I stopped while in the area after hearing good things about the fish fry and boy were they true. Best Fish Fry ever. So good! And the coleslaw is amazing. Next time I go back I just might ask if they'll sell me a bucket of the stuff. I wish I knew the secret to theirs because I rarely like coleslaw let alone think about it afterwards every bit as much as the main protein. Staff was really friendly too. This is definitely a must-try hidden gem.