Review Tony Pepperoni

Sarah

I was really hungry, and this pizza place was the closest one available. I don't understand what the other reviewers meant. This is amazing pizza! It is very fresh and has enough sauce, unlike many other pizza shops. I will be coming back.

Kelly Dillon

Just driving through on vacation and needed that authentic NY slice. They did NOT disappoint. Whole pie for $16? Yes please! Bro even helped us understand the card game we were playing while we waited. Great food (from 2 native long islanders)

DNA Digital Marketing

Alright, I have lived in Henrietta for years now, and have known about Tony Pepperoni in all that time. Not once did I ever seriously consider getting a pizza there. I am a marketer and I thought the name was silly but the logo was even worse. But my step child said that they wanted that pizza. So we got it. What took me so long? This is amazing pizza - the best pizza outside of Rome, Buenos Aires and NYC that I have had. It has to be like the fictitious pizzeria in Billions - Cappanello's. The crust, the sauce it is just great. I like to cook and always try to reverse engineer things I love when I eat out. I surrender. I won't try making my own Tony Pepperoni pizza, there is little hope I can match it and why bother when the price is so reasonable. Love you Tony Pepperoni.

Jeffrey Cellini

Nice restaurant…very clean…good staff….good food

Gregory Muhs

This gluten-free pizza is a work of art! Wonderful pizza and wings. The gentlemen who work here had excellent hospitality. Very good mom and pop pizza place. I highly recommend it!

Megan Van Caeseele-Cook

This is by far the BEST place to get a chicken finger sub. The bread to chicken ratio was perfect. Also, their pizza is delicious. Tony Pepperoni is our families favorite place to get local pizza.

Matthew Lytle

Great food. Never had a bad meal. Beat chicken finger sub.

Jerome Miller

Hands down the best pizza I've had in Rochester reminds me of pizza I used to get in NYC growing up in the Bronx you are truly missing out if you haven't tried Tony Pepperoni yet 💯🔥🔥🔥

Harrison Hicks

Want to acknowledge Ben! He went above and beyond and provided amazing customer service. The world needs more people like him and thank you all for great food!!

Grace Lynch

What a gem! It's a ways out, but it's like small town pizzeria like when I was a kid. Feels like LOCAL pizza, which is not thin like NYC style, nor fat like Chicago deep dish. Local. Just medium thickness, moist crust, generous toppings, lots of cheese, and great prices. They also have slices. Take out, dine in, delivery. What a find. It's worth the drive.

AJ

This place is dishing out some dang good pizza, stopped for a couple slices and they didn't disappoint!

Cre Scott

The pizza is amazing. The sauce is perfecto! I also love the bread for subs. My go to is the steak sub and the Italian assorted. The service is always impeccable and I appreciate their presence in the Town of Henrietta!

Wendy Wilson

I have always enjoyed the food: pizza and wings primarily. I like supporting a smaller business.. a little annoyed tonight though.. when did they start charging a credit card surcharge?. $ 1.98 on my receipt. No mention on the phone when I called and paid for my order either. Would've paid cash. Times are tight, peeps.

Allen Pickard

Lots of options for slices very good pizza,mine was a chicken bacon ranch slice, very thick bacon, was amazing

Jacob LaFex

My family and I were in town visiting from up north. Of course knowing me, I had to order pizza, seems like a family tradition. We ended up ordering from Tony Pepperoni, and we were not disappointed. The food was very warm and fresh still from the delivery. Prices were not horrible for what you are getting. We ordered the traditional plain cheese pizza along with chicken bacon and ranch pizza, and topped it off with the buffalo parmesan garlic wings. The food was excellent and will definitely order again if in the area. Would give more stars if it would let me.

Victoria Ann Zazubec

Their food is great and so is their sauce plus they deliver the food hot and thats worth the 2 buck charge. Most other places charge more then 2 bucks and the food is only warm. I highly recommend Tonys for your next order.

Eric Shaw

Stopped in for lunch. Thin crust was just crispy enough, combinations of toppings and cheese were well seasoned. Two slice special is a great deal!

Laura Edison

I ordered a salad and a side for delivery (less than half a mile away but i didn’t want to drive anywhere else tonight after driving 9 hours today) to my hotel. I was told 30-35 minutes. An hour and 33 minutes later it was delivered!!! I called after an hour and was told it takes at least an hour for delivery.. what? The side was cold and not edible and the salad was not worth $3 let alone $10! Worst service ever!

Davide Venieri

Good taste, nice place and kind staff = great dinner! Dall'Italia, viaggiando in auto tra Boston e Niagara Falls, abbiamo fatto tappa a Rochester, NY. Preso alloggio per la notte in un motel, abbiamo scelto a caso la vostra pizzeria: ottima pizza, ingredienti di qualità (nulla a che vedere con le catene!). In bocca al lupo, ragazzi!

Terra Waddington Rivera

We love pizza that's not "commercialized", and figured we would give this place a try because the price was reasonable compared to other options we had in mind. The pizza was delicious! And there are online coupons that I mentioned over the phone when ordering, and they credited us right then and there; did not have to print / present the coupon.

Paul Mahesh Persaud

Tony, Tony, Tony! I'm a new yorker. I'm from Long Island. I know some good pizza. Your sauce is delicious, however the cheese to sauce ratio was just a little off (I got too little cheese, it tasted more like a utica tomato pie). You came very highly recommended, and maybe if I order again, i'll ask for extra cheese and maybe that'll solve it. But for now, 4/5 stars. Very good.