It was my first time coming in and it definitely won’t be my last.
I took advantage of a promotion they are running buy one get one free. I ordered a meat lovers pie and I got another free.
I placed this order for pick up and head out to pick it up and upon arrival I was Immediately greeted with a big smile. I’m new to the area and don’t come across a lot of welcoming restaurants. It was a simple interaction but such a pleasant one. I got such a warm feeling being there. The staff was so friendly and eager to help.
I’m having the meat lovers now and it is one of the best pizzas I have ever had. I will definitely be buying again and appreciate your business. Thank you
M
Michelle Lc
Google
a year ago
5.0
Had dinner around 6 pm on a Monday night. We ordered two pasta dishes. Food was quick, came with bread and salads. Decent prices overall. The guys manning the front all offered great customer service. Clean bathroom.
T
Tahera triptimony
Google
a year ago
5.0
The best pizzeria ever seriously!! Super amazing staff, very helpful !! I got a catering order from them delivered all the way to ronkonkoma and couldn't be more happier . The food , the experience, the delivery , the price everything was seriously perfect. 1000x recommend .
B
B Swids
Google
a year ago
5.0
I grew up with Sergio's and Carlo's in riverhead. I moved away nearly 30 years ago and everything I come home I stop in and grab a couple slices and garlic knots. The people working there are great, and the pizza and knots never disappoint! Love me Sergio's! Now if they'd open a spot in Maine I'd be in heaven!
J
Jacqueline Buttafuoco
Google
a year ago
5.0
Always happy and full with this pizza whether we pick up or get delivery. Delivery is always fast and the pizza is always hot! The crust is delightful. The staff is friendly. And they are always consistent!
M
Ming K
Google
a year ago
4.0
Everything is cool the Spanish gentleman was helping me out until that lady she didn't even ask me what is my order not even saying thank you she actually just leaving on the table and I have to grab it myself it's not about the Stars it's about how to serve the people the lady was waiting for her order she looks at me and I told her I will never come back here again unless she is not here anymore
A
Antonio Valenciano
Google
3 months ago
5.0
Honestly this is the best pizza I ever tried before. The New York style combined with Italian style; plus the gourmet selection make this place just amazing.
Can't wait to order again!!!
A
Alicia Jones
Google
3 months ago
5.0
Fantastic food and incredibly friendly staff, a huge thanks for Miranda for breaking up a large order that I needed multiple receipts for with efficiency and kindness. Will absolutely be back!
M
moses burdon
Google
7 months ago
4.0
a great example of a classic New York slice, friendly employees as always.
Sergio's has always been great pizza.
P
Philip Ferrato
Google
7 months ago
5.0
The best pizzeria in Riverhead! Also a little more expensive but worth it. Love the panini on homemade rolls.
T
Tracy Mtz
Google
8 months ago
5.0
We ordered pizza on Ubereats. We were so hungry and didn't feel like going out, the pizza was really good.
C
Chef Omar Baker
Google
4 years ago
5.0
The best pizza in NY always everything it at its best here eat here everytime I visit NY
