Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
71/100
Data Completeness
67/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🚚
Delivery
🥡
Takeout
📷 Photos (10+)
+2
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 10
100%
Google Reviews
140
Google reviews
Layout/atmosphere
*Ordered through front door window (could not go inside)
Food/drink
*Chocolate Salted Caramel cupcake (Chocolate cupcake frosted with salted caramel swiss buttercream, homemade salted caramel drizzle & maldon sea salt) - Good; rich; salty touch was needed [favorite]
*Brooklyn Blackout cupcake (Chocolate cupcake filled and topped with chocolate pudding coated in chocolate cake crumbs) - Good; also rich; portions on smaller side but understandable given the ingredients/texture
Read more
Google
My spouse and I were craving something sweet, so we decided to explore nearby bakeries. That's when we stumbled upon Buttah bakery. Let me tell you, I developed a deep appreciation for cupcakes after this visit. While I haven't tried their cakes yet, the cupcakes were a revelation. They were incredibly fresh, succulent, soft, moist, and bursting with flavor – they practically melted in my mouth. I tried a Brooklyn blackout, a coconut cupcake, a tres leche, and a vanilla one. To this day, I can still savor the deliciousness. These cupcakes were clearly crafted with love and care. Without a doubt, Buttah is the best bakery I've ever come across. If you have any doubts, I urge you to experience it for yourself. You have absolutely nothing to lose. These treats are made from scratch, and the lady who runs the place was delightful.
Read more
Google
Their frosting is MAGICAL. So fluffy, beautiful and perfect. Every single guest that tried the cupcake was blown away. The service is also outstanding! We ordered cupcakes for my daughter’s birthday over a holiday weekend and they were kind enough t to accommodate us outside of business hours and were even understanding when we were running late (sorry and thank you so much!)
Read more
Google
We got a chocolate cake with American buttercream. Everyone kept asking where it was from. Absolutely delicious and fresh!
Google
This bakery came through in a pinch. We needed special containers for our Charlotte Russe cakes, and Buttah shipped them all the way to CA! My Dad was so touched that he was able to eat this wonderful dessert for his 90th Birthday!
Google
First off, the frosting on the cupcake and cake I got were soooo good, it’s not too sweet and holds up well in the fridge. As for the actual cake, it was fine, paired well with the frosting but was a bit lacking in flavor would have preferred a slightly more moist cake.
Google
A gem in Ridgewood......so excited when this opened and it has never disappointed. I'm obsessed with the Cinnamon Sugar Muffins!!! Corn Brulee Bread pudding is a must.... They have a variety of cupcake flavors and cookies!! And they make amazing cakes for all occasions!!
Google
I really love this bakery! I’ve ordered three cakes in the past couple of months and each one was better than the next! Coconut Cream, Tres Leches, and Par-Tay bday cake were all perfect and I can’t wait to order another one soon! Ordering on their website was really convenient. Also, I had to email them with a question and Stacy was so sweet and accommodating with my requests. Wonderful neighborhood bakery!
Read more
Google
Overall I have 4.5 for desserts I got but 5 for the price, portion, and the presentation!
✨🍌🥜Banana Peanut Buttah cupcake was my favorite! The cake was moist, soft, with the cream, the flavor was wonderful and rich. (My friend had the blackout cupcake and she loved it too.)
I couldn’t give the Tres Leches cake a super high score since I have my No.1 in mind but still, they did a great job. Plus, the price was reasonable.
The taste of sour cream cheese cake didn’t fit my preference but it is an outstanding cake with a crunchy biscuit layer at the bottom.
Would like to try different cupcakes since they are good at baking the cake part!
Read more
Google
This bakeshop is absolutely delectable. Everything we tried was delicious. The creative bakers here offer some incentive ideas too, such as a corn creme brûlée and jalapeño, cheddar cream, cheese scone. A must try!
Google
Explore more in Ridgewood
By specialty
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: