Nicholas

Can’t recommend. First visit since new name. Disappointing experience. I had the “Nicholas” burger and it came out rare even though I asked for medium well. Also for a “signature” burger it had nothing special. Paid extra for French fries and they were undercooked and rubbery. Wife had salmon and it was overcooked and dry. Ended with apple crisp which came out cold. Waiter noticed our reaction and said, “Did yours come out cold too?” Obviously we were not the only ones. He took it off our bill without us even asking. Overall felt like we could have had a better meal at a chain restaurant for half the price.

One of best places to dine in New Jersey. We celebrated our anniversary here and loved the food. The French onion soup is a perfect start to your dinner plans. All cocktails are beautiful composed and will make you to crave more. Staff here is very nice and cheerful. Only thing we felt disheartened was that we didn’t receive an anniversary plating of desert(my wife was kinda sad for missing out on blowing candle since we saw pictures of other parties celebrating birthdays and anniversary here).

It was a beautiful and tasty, fun eating dinner with my fella. It was his birthday, and our waitress surprised my fella with a gigantic, delicious banana split with sparkling lights to honor his day. Filet Mignon and Short Rib are awesome, well prepared, and yummy. Danced on my tongue! ----review by Joseph's girlfriend

We were in the area & looking for a great place for dinner & drinks. We found Nicholas Barrel & Roost & decided to give it a try. What a great vibe as we walked thru a busy restaurant. The bar had seating so we sat close to the drinktender. Great decision as our server was knowledgeable & friendly. We ordered drinks & dinner… as we enjoyed the bourbons & beers, the entrees came out. We had Grilled Swordfish, Crusted Halibut & the Spare Rib. All of the entrees were beautifully plated and equally delicious! We will be back when our travel brings us to this area. Thanks for the friendly service, Neha!