The service was quite pleasant, and the food was prepared perfectly. My Mom and I will likely come back here again when I'm in the Puyallup area to visit.
I would highly recommend trying the fettuccine with pesto sauce and street festival sausage. It is so delicious!
Although I hadn’t had Italian food recently, I thought the meals we ordered online was pretty good and both me and my wife want to visit in person. I ordered a small Casa Mia Classic Spaghetti with Basil Pesto Sauce and had chicken added. I thought it was very very good and wish I ordered a large. The pasta basil sauce was really good. My wife ordered a small Butternut Squash Ravioli with Fresh Herb Butter and Parmigiano. What she most liked was how creamy it was and how the flavors really popped. This first impression is pretty impressive and can’t wait to try more. Why 4 stars? I want the in-house experience 😊!
The staff were very friendly and attentive. The chef came out to the tables to make sure everyone was happy with their food. I had the Carbonara and it was so delicious. I have rarely been to a local place where the chef comes out to check on the diners and I really enjoyed that. Prices were good and the place is cozy.
This is the BEST restaurant for Italian food and my favorite restaurant in general! The service is impeccable and the food is absolutely to die for. I always recommend that my friends and family go here. I would put more than 5 stars if I could. This place deserves to be packed full of customers every day and night.
Listen, have I had better Italian food than Casa Mia? The answer is yes BUT somehow I keep on coming back! Service is always great, even when they are short staffed. We always order the house side salad with ranch. It’s really just lettuce, mozzarella cheese, black olives and drenched in ranch dressing. I honestly order the salad because of the ranch.
They used to bring out a garlicky bread before but this time they brought out a basket of knotted bread with Parmesan cheese on it. It wasn’t bad but I think it could stay in the oven a little longer.
For the main dish my husband always gets the spinach and cheese ravioli and I get the chicken carbonara. They are both delicious. The carbonara is definitely an American style carbonara since it has bacon and comes in a pool of white sauce but it’s good.
Casa Mia serves tasty Americanized Italian food and I’m not mad at it. Try them, you’ll be coming back.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes