Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
58/100
Data Completeness
56/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
Contact Information
📞
Phone:
+1 253-770-0400
🌐 Website:
http://casamiarestaurants.com
📍
Address:
505 Meridian Ave E, Puyallup
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
761
Google reviews
Extremely disappointed in our service today. We made a fairly large order online for a work treat, many of the items that showed up were wrong, our preferences were obviously ignored including my pasta dish showing up with a cream sauce and not the basil pesto, and to add insult to injury all I could taste was the noodles since no one took the effort to season the cream sauce I didn’t order.
My coworkers found their food generally appealing, but with the number of issues with one order and their in attention to detail when it comes to online orders I highly recommend NOT ordering food here and dining in only where you can make them correct the things they get wrong.
Read more
Google
The service was quite pleasant, and the food was prepared perfectly. My Mom and I will likely come back here again when I'm in the Puyallup area to visit.
I would highly recommend trying the fettuccine with pesto sauce and street festival sausage. It is so delicious!
Google
Although I hadn’t had Italian food recently, I thought the meals we ordered online was pretty good and both me and my wife want to visit in person. I ordered a small Casa Mia Classic Spaghetti with Basil Pesto Sauce and had chicken added. I thought it was very very good and wish I ordered a large. The pasta basil sauce was really good. My wife ordered a small Butternut Squash Ravioli with Fresh Herb Butter and Parmigiano. What she most liked was how creamy it was and how the flavors really popped. This first impression is pretty impressive and can’t wait to try more. Why 4 stars? I want the in-house experience 😊!
Read more
Google
The staff were very friendly and attentive. The chef came out to the tables to make sure everyone was happy with their food. I had the Carbonara and it was so delicious. I have rarely been to a local place where the chef comes out to check on the diners and I really enjoyed that. Prices were good and the place is cozy.
Read more
Google
This is the BEST restaurant for Italian food and my favorite restaurant in general! The service is impeccable and the food is absolutely to die for. I always recommend that my friends and family go here. I would put more than 5 stars if I could. This place deserves to be packed full of customers every day and night.
Read more
Google
We ordered a large pizza and 2 salads with shrimp, one without olives.
Both salads had olives, the lettuce was hardly chopped, and neither had shrimp even though that's what we paid for.
Onto the "well done" pizza (although they did not ask how we would like it cooked?)... The pizza had half melted cheese and the dough towards the middle of the pizza was mostly uncooked. We ended up having to put the pizza in the oven at home to finish cooking the pizza for them.
$50 for some roughly chopped lettuce, olives, a little bit of cheese, and an undercooked pizza with half melted cheese. Needless to say we will not be back.
The only reason I gave the second star to this review is simply because we received food in exchange for money.
Read more
Google
We waited over 45 minutes to get our food when there was only another couple in the restaurant when we arrived. It got busy fast and we watched other customers eat before us. When I mentioned how long we've been waiting to the waitress, she responded by saying she didn't have control over how fast the kitchen can make the food which frankly is rude to say to customers. I've only ordered delivery from this restaurant in the past and the Chicken Carbonara is delicious! Our first dine in will be our last. I ordered something different this time and was not impressed. Food was bland and is over priced for the experience. Will be looking for other Italian Restaurants! I do not recommend this place.
Read more
Google
Listen, have I had better Italian food than Casa Mia? The answer is yes BUT somehow I keep on coming back! Service is always great, even when they are short staffed. We always order the house side salad with ranch. It’s really just lettuce, mozzarella cheese, black olives and drenched in ranch dressing. I honestly order the salad because of the ranch.
They used to bring out a garlicky bread before but this time they brought out a basket of knotted bread with Parmesan cheese on it. It wasn’t bad but I think it could stay in the oven a little longer.
For the main dish my husband always gets the spinach and cheese ravioli and I get the chicken carbonara. They are both delicious. The carbonara is definitely an American style carbonara since it has bacon and comes in a pool of white sauce but it’s good.
Casa Mia serves tasty Americanized Italian food and I’m not mad at it. Try them, you’ll be coming back.
Read more
Google
Explore more in Puyallup
By cuisine
By specialty
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: