Old Mill Brew Pub & Grill

Have passed this place many times and never stopped in before this week. Burger was fantastic, fries were cooked perfectly, both beers I tried were excellent, service was great. I feel like the way they executed (properly cooked burger, crispy fresh fries, top-notch service) says a lot about their attentiveness to their business and their customers. Stop in and you will not be disappointed!

Great location, really enjoyed trotting through plain well to get here. Adjacent to plain well ice cream. Food was mediocre, home made chips were alright (kinda bland and inconsistent texture). Parmesan fries basket was pricey for the small portion we received. Flavor was alright and the cheese didn’t stick the greatest. I ordered the California Ruben and it was good! I appreciated the crispness of the bread, but would only rate it a 7/10 due to its blandish flavor. I would recommend adding more oomph to the slaw/ thousand island. My family members got the sweet potato fries with their buffalo chicken wrap entree and those were awesome! I highly recommend. The chicken wrap itself was alright. My partner had the Box Car BLT, it was good but also pretty dry. She recommends buttered bread and adding more sauce of sorts. Drinks were great! My partner was especially happy they had a sweetened wine to sip. Service was good. I appreciate the swiftness. Atmosphere was good, classic pub/bar feel with a bit of a barn twist. (Also check out the hall they have an awesome pezz dispenser display)! Overall there is some work to be done, my main concern was the price. I understand things are expensive now a days, but with a raise in price should come with a raise in quality. Either way my family and I had a great time! Lovely spot.

We've been coming to Old Mill for a long time and have always enjoyed the atmosphere and good service. Always felt they're a bit high on the menu though. Especially the Burrito ($17) that does NOT come with any sides like rice and beans. Didn't realize there's a $2.50 up charge for tator tots either until we paid our bill today, and there were only 12 tots on the place. Think we'll wait awhile before going back.

Best micro brew beer I've ever tasted. The Crazy Beaver Cream Ale was simply a damned good satisfying beer. Smooth and full bodied to the last drop. The food was just as fresh, tasty and flavorful. I had the fried perch basket. The fish was light, moist and flaky with just the right amount of crispy coating. My only regret was I didn't find this place sooner.

I have driven by this place many times over the years and always said I was going to try it, well I finally did and I was not disappointed. The place is beautiful inside and out! I love how they kept as much of the old mill stuff intact. They have the best PEZ dispenser collection I have ever seen. The food was delicious and didn't take a long time to make. Their fries were delicious and the shrimp was spot on. I will definitely be going back to this place!

Dinner was good. Ordered the Ranch Chicken Wrap needs a little more chicken in it and less lettuce. On the plus side I wLettuce. Husband ordered the perch, 4 pieces all were good sizes, popular dish. Nice history building, the Pezz collection caught my eye. So many of them 😀. Yes, we will go back to eat again.