Pizza Stop
3349 Monroe Ave, 14618-5513 - Pittsford
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#37 of 45 restaurants in Pittsford
Updated on
Pizza
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
62/100
Data Completeness
67/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🚚
Delivery
🥡
Takeout
🍽️
Dine-in
🍺
Alcohol
📅
Reservations
♿
Wheelchair accessible
😊
Casual
Contact Information
📞
Phone:
+1 585-662-5513
🌐 Website:
http://www.pizzastop1.com
📍
Address:
3349 Monroe Ave, Pittsford
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
185
Google reviews
Came here today with my daughter to grab a slice while she had the day off. Neither of us were disappointed by the slices.
The cheese was perfectly done and the crust was thin with just the right amount of crispness after reheated in the oven. I will be coming back here for more slices in the future.
White pizza and veggie topped pizzas were available at the time we visited. Enjoy!
Read more
Google
The best pizza in town. Our family’s favorite pizza, we have been customers for over 13 years.
Google
This is the closest to authentic New York pizza that you can get by far in the greater Rochester area! The place is very nicely decorated and always clean. We recommend the buffalo chicken pizza. The prices are fair and the toppings are generous, I can't say too much about the service because we've only ever ordered takeout but the time it takes between ordering and the food being ready is standard.
Read more
Google
Bless pizza stop. Perfect pizza, great cookies too. Staff is always nice. I stop in multiple times a week
Google
The pizza is pretty amazing here and the service is always great too. I recommend trying them out if you haven't just yet. Their pies are that good!
Google
By far the best pizza in the area. I grew up outside NYC and it's the closest thing to real NYC pizza. Good variety too- kid loves the calzones. Only complaint is their hours don't seem to be consistent; several times I went to pick up some slices and they were closed in the middle of the day. Also, they're closed on Sundays- too bad, they'd get lots of business during football season.
Read more
Google
Perfect place to pick up slices while in the Pittsford Plaza. Lots of variety in their whole pizzas (Love the chicken sesame). Prices for slices are affordable, and whole pizzas are average. Staff is friendly and atmosphere is exactly what you would want out of a local pizza joint. Only had a mistake happen once, and it was corrected quickly, easily, and ended up with additional pizza.
Read more
Google
Ordered delivery- pizza arrived quickly and hot. Generous amount of toppings, reasonable price. Not too greasy, good flavor— though not a sweet sauce (which I personally prefer). My favorite aspect of this pizza is their crust. I ordered their thin crust- which was quite good. Just the right amount of crisp, yet warm and soft on the inside… also, awesome flavor to the crust.
Read more
Google
Stop in for a couple slices at lunch. I was the a bit before noon and it was pretty quiet, but when the lunch crowd came in it got pretty busy!
I grabbed a couple slices and a drink for about $10. Both the white and the red slices were super tasty and the bottom had a slight crunch (just the way I like it!). Great NY style slice!
Read more
Google
Best thin crust pizza I've had anywhere in the area. Service quick & friendly. Decor very cool graffiti art representing the 5 boroughs. Highly recommend dropping I'm for a slice!
Google
Explore more in Pittsford
By cuisine
By specialty
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: