Prohibition Pastries

Eliza at Prohibition Pastries is an absolute dream to work with. My sister lives in Pittsburgh and had a birthday coming up; I was devastated (being in New England) that I would not be able to be with her and share a slice of cake, especially with the way the world is now. I reached out to Prohibition Pastries to see if they would be willing to create a birthday cake and deliver it to her door as a surprise. Fortunately, the proximity was close and they were able to accommodate my request. I received responses immediately and we began collaborating on the final product. The cake was beautiful and I felt supported by Eliza throughout the remote planning process. I received pictures from my sister of her birthday cake along with "ugly crying" and a heartfelt "thank you". Eliza and Prohibition Pastries allowed my sister's birthday to feel more special than usual- I am endlessly grateful for their business and would highly recommend them to anyone. Cheers from Maine!

This place is amazing! I stumbled across it when looking for a caterer for my bridal shower at PointBreezeway. The shower was this past weekend and the food was soo good. Many of the guests at the shower commented on how much they loved the food. It's different and delicious and was perfect for what we were looking for. They even waived the delivery fee since the venue was just a few houses down. Thanks so much for all of your help, Eliza!

These guys knocked it out of the park for my daughter's 4th birthday. The picture doesn't do it justice. It's a flower cake with a flock of pterodacyls flying over head. They also did flower and dino cookies to pair with the theme. Per her request, the cake was strawberry. The bakery surprised us with berry filling between the layers. The guests did not complain. :-) Watch out when you go pick up your order, though. The savory handpies are hard to say no to.

Very cute shop & very nice pastries! Ordered a custom cake, was disappointed in the quality for the price. Cake texture was dry and heavy, filling tasted like store-bought jam- too sweet, no fresh fruit, icing was just ok- no "flair" that seems to be prevalent in the pastries, e.g., use of spirits, herb/spice. I would absolutely come here again for the pastries, but not cakes, unless you specify clearly what you want and how you want it.