Toby's Cup

Saw a list of the top places in Jersey to grab a dog and on this list, was Toby's Cup. Only about 45 minutes from my house so figured out some other stuff to do in the area and went to grab a bite. Found out after I arrived that the place had somewhat recently been purchased by a new owner and he had kept most of the menu the same but added a few small changes. One of those changes being fries. The old owner rocked a bunch of chips and stuff from what I understand but didn't do fries. I'm happy the new owner does fries. These fries were fresh cut, hot and crisp, and delicious. I would go back just for the fries. The burger was also very good. Had a nice flavor, good amount of meat, and a tasty roll. The dog was quite good as well. A good hearty chili served here with onions and mustard. Overall the price was solid and I'd definitely go back when in the area. The staff was also friendly and the food came out quickly. This would be 5 star but the location isn't super friendly with the traffic and parking lot and the inside is small with no tables except for a fe picnic tables for outdoor seating attached to the parking lot.

Bad enough it's $2.25 for a Hot Dog but would be nice if they were ever open. Over the past 2 weeks I've come here 4 times and they were closed with no reason posted. This time it says will be closed Monday and reopen Tuesday. It was Thursday evening and sign was still up. That means they weren't even there for 4 days to take the sign down. No notice, nothing on website, Facebook, nothing. Waste of gas to get nothing. With just go to Hotdog Johnny's for now on

1st time trying since reopened and was very unhappy. I understand the prices of things are higher, but the portion of cheese fries for the price was a joke. Made the shakes first then waitied half hour for food to take home overpriced cup of cold milk. Then when paying with a card, was told I had to leave a tip, then went back and forth until it was understood that I didnt. Will not be back, way better options in the area.

Toby's cup has been a Warren county favorite since the dawn of time. With it's hard to miss building and sign, it's a place that bonds to ones memory easily. The smells, the sights, the oil laden odors waft on to 22, tempting me mercilessly on every drive past. I've been going to several years. Many regulars assure me that the quality and taste is the same as it was in 1946. America, fresh off the victory of world war ii revels in a boom of culinary delight. Toby's is born. A true American icon, and relic of a past gone by. The hot dogs are gently fried and served with "everything" aka onion, mustard, and pickles. The sour, savory, salty cacophony must be accompanied with a sugary beverage for optimal enjoyment. Second to none, I recommend a milkshake accompanyment. I enjoy it, but a dream of yesteryear like this will someday fade into a memory. The times will catch up. Don't take it personally, but the chefs don't care how your day is going. Please order your food, and savor in American history.