Anyone who knows me, knows that I'm passionate about cheese and all artisan foods.
I started Petoskey Cheese in October of 2015 to bring my favorite foods in a new space and to be as approachable + educational as possible.
I have learned a lot as a business owner. Of course, we have had our ups and downs. The cheese shop is an honest reflection of me every day: some days we are busy and brisk, while other days you will get a mini 101 lesson with each cheese you try.
At the shop, we aspire to provide the best possible customer experience to everyone that walks in. We encourage all of our customers to carve out some time, keep an open mind, and try some new products.
I thank you all for taking the time to visit this page or the shop, and for all of your continued support. Please know that we're doing the best we can and we wouldn't be able to do it without you.
The cheese shop in Petosky is nothing short of fabulous!
We purchased a grab bag they have. The cheese , crackers, olives & murabba was unique & delicious. If you have never heard murabba go to the shop and ask ,It'll be well worth it .
I have been wanting to try this place for awhile now, but don't drive downtown very often. We'll today I finally got to! Though they didn't have any grilled sandwiches, I didn't care much as I just wanted to try a spread of different cheeses. First off the customer service was great! She knew exactly what every cheese was and explained them very well. She was excited to show me different cheese trays and you could tell she took pride in her work and that it is her passion. Well I was very excited to try the cheese and salami tray and had very high expectations... I was not disappointed! The variety of cheeses had such good flavor and the textures were amazing. I will definitely be back! I am a cheese lover and this place will be on my list to visit often! This is a must try for anyone that loves cheese!
Called in an order for 2 Caprese sandwiches on a Tuesday afternoon. Stopped by 15 minutes later and they were ready... and amazing. Excellent bread, flavorful, slightly sweet tomato, well-balanced pesto, and of course perfect mozzeralla! Best sandwich I've had in downtown Petoskey. It was $10, which is on the lower end of sandwich prices downtown. Will return!
This place came highly recommended by several friends. It’s a small store on E. Mitchell in Petoskey. We sampled several cheeses and bought all but one. We bought Prairie Breeze Cheddar, Porter Marbled, Mango Ginger (dessert cheese) and Jalapeño Cilantro Jack. (I can’t remember what type they all were.) We also tasted another one called Balsamic Parmesan and it was VERY good, but we didn’t buy it. The staff wasn’t overly friendly, not the day we went (11/17/18), but by the end of the visit, she was talking a bit more. We also bought some chutney that we were able to sample. I highly recommend. There’s a smaller jar for $5.95 but it’s really small.
I ordered three cheese trays from Petoskey Cheese for my husband and I’s August elopement, and they were the ultimate hit at our appetizer table. Our family and friends couldn’t stop talking about them! Katie was so friendly and informative in helping me place the order, and included a huge variety of amazing cheeses that everyone was excited to sample (the double cream Brie is everything!!). I would order from Petoskey Cheese again in a heartbeat!
Very good selection of Cheeses, and other assorted goodies. Yummy sandwiches also available. Parking is easy.
One of my favorite places in town! The daily sandwiches are excellent and the Take n' Bake mac and cheese is killer! My personal favorite are the naan bread pizzas! There is not one that I don't like, all of them are absolutely delicious. Many different delicious cheeses to choose from. I love the end pieces of cheese you can buy for a buck or two at the register. It's a great way to try new cheeses you've never had before. Any questions about cheese, Katie is your girl! She is very knowledgeable and educated her staff very well. Highly recommend!
Great selection, wonderful freshness, kind and courteous staff. Good luck in your new location. We’ll see you there… soon, we hope.
Unbelievable spread for my brother's wedding. I could have stood at the table all night. I loved the selection and presentation - so creative and professional. These girls HIT it out of the park. we did run out of crackers so I would recommend they leave a few boxes for refill, but otherwise the best food of the day!
Katie was so fun and knowledgeable. She created a customized wine/beer & cheese pairing class for our work group that was interesting, helpful, and enjoyable. I’ve never found a cheese I haven’t liked, but Katie’s expertise showed me what true cheesemongering looks like. Thank you for a world class experience!
We purchased a platter for a get together with friends and were very happy with the outcome. The platter was well designed and offered a great assortment to suit varying palettes. We will definitely use them again in the future.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Petoskey
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes