The best Alfredo in Pensacola | Sluurpy updated in May

Bonelli's Cafe Italia

87/100 (2008 ratings)

Restaurants

Gluten Free Options

Italian

Vegan Options

Italian

Vegetarian Friendly

Gluten Free Options

Vegan Options

Dinner

Eggplant

Pasta

Salad

Alfredo

Meatballs

Lasagne

Chicken Parmesan

Pesto

Shrimp

Sit down

Italian

Seating

Table Service

Wheelchair Accessible

Serves Alcohol

Full Bar

Outdoor Seating

Takeout

Reservations

Dinner

Mid-range

"Wonderful experience here! Marina was our server and she was amazing! Joey came over and told us about the specials. We had apps, main course, wine,..."

Sonny

"Great food!. Everything tastes homemade, the owner and staff make you feel like you are part of their family.Don't judge it by the looks on the..."

Snoopy

"My family and I came here to eat on vacation and I have to say Best Italian food EVER!!! The food was amazing... authentic cooking!!!! And the..."

Frances Guidry

"Best Food and Service!!!!. My husband took me here for my birthday because I was craving Italian. Best birthday meal I have had in a while!!!!..."

Brandimichellemoore

"Best Italian We Have Found In Pcola. I have been wanting to try this place out for awhile, and finally had the opportunity on Saturday night after..."

Arnold Newton

"A rare find in Pensacola! Great food, authentic Italian cooking. Not from a can, not frozen processed food, not phony. This is the real deal ! The..."

Peridot

"Fabulous would be the one word that sums it up. To start the salad was as fresh as the items in my home garden! The appetizer was amazing. And then..."

Tony

"Genuine, authentic cooking. Not from a can, not frozen processed food. This is the real deal ! Everything is fresh, and they have SPUMONI..."

Susan

"Really nice atmosphere and great service although my eggplant Parmesan was really really buttery... I guess that's some people's taste but I prefer..."

Lauren Alexandra Vassiliades

"Forgot--Really?. This is Gina Bonelli from Bonelli’s Café Italia. While I certainly apologize that you feel as though we forgot you, I can assure..."

Gina Bonelli

"Delighted with Bonelli's. We ate here for a friend’s birthday party last night and had a rather large group. We found the restaurant to be inviting..."

Foodie Fan

"Awesome. Great atmosphere and delicious! Also, the people were so personable, and they went out of their way to accommodate one member of our group..."

Lindmaclaren

"High Quality Ingredients, Beautifully Combined. We really enjoyed our visit to Bonelli's. I liked best that we could specify ingredients on our..."

PatrMcGraw

"Food, Family, Fun!. First, I have to admit that I am a friend of the Bonelli's, so those of you who think that will affect my review can stop reading..."

Rebecca

"Best little Family owned place in town. I love to go to Bonelli's. They are friendly and the place is clean, service is wonderful, and the food is..."

Triggers Seafood Restaruant

"Everything was delicious.. Started with a glass of red wine recommended by the server. That really set the mood as it was a fantastic glass of wine...."

Emily Martin

"First time at lunch. Baked Ziti with a Negroni. Ziti al dente. This is not the dreaded five-cheeses iteration. Sauce was well-balanced and showed..."

Jane Buttram

"Delicious. Decided to try this place tonight as we're always on the lookout for delicious Italian food.Everything we tried was delicious..."

Helen Sewell

"FANTASTIC!!!. This was an exceptional place to eat. We arrived and were the only ones there (early Monday evening). The appetizer and wine were..."

Salgal1710

"I had a business luncheon at Bonelli's on Thursday and I was very impressed. Although I have not tried the entree's yet, I had their Greek Salad and..."

Gourmet Mom

"Bonelli's. I love their Chicken Parmesan!! It is soooo cheesy & delicious. They have a bread appetizer with their variety of sauces and it is the..."

Cindy

"Wonderful experience. We had a great meal at Bonelli's last night! We were the only people in the restaurant, but we did arrive a little early (and..."

Kay

"Delicious times two. Yum...no wait...double YUM! There were six of us that dined here on a Tuesday night. The place was pretty empty. It doesn't look..."

Brittani

"A small cafe that we enjoy often. The Alfredo pasta is unique and delicious. The grinder are excellent as well. Very good..."

Citivolus Sus

"Bonelli's best kept secret in town!. Honestly I am a very busy person and usually do not take the time to post on any site and certainly do not take..."

A Better Food Snob

"Awesome. Foodsnob, you're an idiot. I go here often and they are always above par. Who would listen to someone who's only reviews are here and then..."

GourmetBaby

"You didn't like the cats?. I actually love the fact that they have cats roaming around. It reminds me a lot like Greece. Also the atmosphere makes it..."

Roger Oak

"AMAZING. There is not many places you can get homemade food these days. Most are pre bought processed food. How can processed food be really good for..."

The Pouty Princess

"Delicious!!. Best spaghetti and meatballs I have had in Pensacola. My boyfriend had lasagna and loved it. Sauce was not too acidic like New York..."

Kbolkeny

"Cute little Italian place. Lots of sandwich options, but not as many pasta options. Wonderful nonetheless, and the chocolate cake is to die for. Ask..."

Rachel Cassady

"Hidden gem in Pensacola! This Italian restaurant is one you won’t want to miss. The food was delicious. Their menu doesn’t lie when it says the..."

Phillip Metcalfe

"The food is rated so well, I hate to leave anything contrary. My wife is the Italian fan so I’ll * her part. For starters, we didn’t have a..."

Randall McGuire

"Cozy small restaurant, with authentic food, generous portions, awesome food quality, and world class service. Waitress was Hannah and the owner..."

Ogre Ray

"Friendly atmosphere and most of all, great food!!! Reasonable price. Worth the wait if you have to. Highly recommend ..."

heacho

"Listen here. To all yall 1/2 star reviewers... how could yall say anything negative about this restaurant!? Everyone contributed to my great..."

VeSean Bogan

"We took my daughter here for her 14th birthday. The food is great. The portions are big. The prices match what you get. You have to make a..."

Monica S. Jackson

"Had an amazing couples dinner. Great service, portions were more than suitable for our stomachs, and the staff are incredibly kind and attentive. I..."

James Nguyen

"The five star ratings given for Bonelli's are all so much deserved. The aroma in the air was the first sign, I knew my meal would be tasty. Just a..."

ReneeOnPoint

"This was the best pasta I’ve ever had, would 10/10 recommend. The service was great as well, and the food was a bit slow but you could tell it was..."

Joel Sexson

"Food was excellent, but a bit pricey especially if you want to add any protien to your pasta an sauce. But every dish I tried was delicious, will..."

Ashley Dearing

"The food was excellent. But the overall experience was a little mixed. We had reservations for 7:00. We didn't get seated until after 7:30 and we..."

Travis Meyer

"Had dinner here tonight. Did not have a reservation but they worked us in. Had the House Special and Roman’s Dirty Oil and Garlic.. Both were so..."

mal thompson

"We made reservations for four on a Friday night. We were seated immediately. Our server, Amy was friendly, efficient and very knowledgable. Charming..."

Jeffrey Cowgill

"Italy is on my bucket list, one day I hope to go. I've always wondered how true Italian food tastes until today, I think I have an idea now...."

Ingrid Rodgers

"The best hidden gem for Italian homemade food in pensacola. Amazing environment and incredible staff. Justin was the bar tender and even though we..."

Hunter Lumley

"I can't say enough good things about this spot. My wife and I had heard great things, but it took us a while to make our way here. I've never had..."

Chris B.

"Corky but really COOL vibe . The food was excellent. Wow! Logan was an outstanding server. Will definitely be back on our next..."

M Khodayari

"Everything from scratch!! Worth the wait!! Staff is awesome especially" Alli " thank you. Outside patio was attractive with live easy listening..."

David Jansen

"Atmosphere and ambience was so calming. If you're looking for a hearty meatball definitely go here. Also red sauce is on point!!!!! Ashleigh was my..."

grey barona

Lillian's Pizza

77/100 (4370 ratings)

Restaurants

Pizza

Vegetarian Friendly

Italian

Pizza

Italian

Vegan Options

Vegetarian Friendly

Vegan Options

Dinner

Lunch

Late Night

Shrimp

Pasta

Salad

Wings

Crab

Alfredo

Meatballs

Lasagne

Sandwiches

Pesto

Sit down

Pizza

Italian

Takeout

Television

Seating

Table Service

Wheelchair Accessible

Serves Alcohol

Parking Available

Highchairs Available

Full Bar

Accepts Credit Cards

Delivery

Outdoor Seating

Dinner

Late Night

Lunch

Mid-range

"Delivered on time. Pizza is delicious. Boys loved it. Cheese stuffed bread sticks are awesome. We were thoroughly happy with all of it. We will..."

Meredith Ann Carter

"Best pizza in orange beach area. I love the thick pan pizza. Ingredients are always fresh, service is always great. We have been coming here for..."

JD718

"Nice family place and hardly ever a wait. The pizza is good, and they do a killer take out business. Clean. Staff is friendly and..."

Brian Creely

"Best pizza in the area! I love a crispy thin crust pizza and Lillian's is the best! My personal preference is to order from the menu, I believe the..."

Dina McDaniel

"THE place to get pizza on those vacation nights when you'd rather just enjoy the view of the ocean from your own condo balcony. I highly recommend..."

Amy

"Food: Pizza was decent. However, during the lunch crowd, the back had trouble keeping up and there was a time where nothing much was available...."

Patrick Bateman

"We visited for dinner on a Saturday night. We ate outside with our two young boys. The service was excellent- even though our server had to keep an..."

Megan

"Great food, great service!. The food was delicious, had a Greek salad and the Italian supreme pan pizza. Wish we had thought to take a picture before..."

Pmsrace

"Great food!. I have loved everything I have tried. The pizza and lasagna are..."

Jim 850

"I eat here all the time and the pizza is really good especially the one with 5 different cheeses. The only negative to this restraunt is that it will..."

Captain Cook 👨‍🍳

"Order the lasagna, not Pizza. I don't get the fuss over their pizza. The crust was extremely boring. I ate here three times over my visit..."

DinerP

"Big Dave's meat lovers is..."

Tommy

"Great pizza. Order well before you want to eat even if it's takeout because they are busy and it takes..."

Nicole Hunt Canter

"Good, Not Great. Ordered take out tonight from there. A Taco Pizza and Pesto Pizza. Won't be getting the taco pizza again, but the pesto is pretty..."

Missdiner

"Best pizza on any beach anywhere...Ms Lillian is the owner. After losing the first Lillians to Hurrican Ivan, she opened this one across the street...."

Billy Kemp

"Lilliana pan pizza is hands down the best pizza I've ever had, I love the place great open bar good drinks great staff . I would waste my time going..."

Dave

"Our server was a total sweetheart! The food was fast. The veggie patch pizza was decent, but really I pity the pizza that goes up against my locals...."

Alanna Maloney

"Everything was great... Except the crab pizza. Avoid that..."

Eric Mitz

"Tasty Long time diner. I'm willing to overlook the Florida gator statue at the door and take a seat. Menu is good, and consistently done well...."

Brian C

"Really good food!. There are not many places to eat in Perdido Key, but Lillian's definitely makes up for it! We stayed at Eden Condominium and they..."

Frank

"Slow service but.... I like Lillian's Pizza. Every time I've eaten in, the service was slooooow. Other than that the pizza is good. I'd give it a 6.5..."

Howie

"Best pizza in Pensacola. Their pizza is SO good! High quality ingredients always delivered piping hot. Service IN the restaurant is sometimes slow,..."

Sara

"Delivery into Orange Beach where we were staying, and a good but not great..."

Jerry

"Good for price. Its a local place and is good. i have never had a bad experience there and i have eaten there 10 times or..."

Budk1313

"Not to shabby. The pizza was very good, bit pricey but at least they have a full bar here. Staff was friendly and efficient. The place it's self is a..."

Have Fork Will Travel

"Beach Pizza. Found in Perdido Key just across from the gulf on the sound side. This place serves great pizzas and a wide variety on the menu. You..."

Dareon

"Pizza was awesome, but the service was very..."

Dorothy

"This is must have pizza if your on the..."

Wesley

"Great Pizza!. I'm sure like everyone else, I miss the old beach location, but the pizza still rocks. Been going here for..."

Carlos

"Best pizza on the beach. Homemade. Pasta not so..."

Lilypond

"The pizza was excellent. The best pizza my hubby said he has ever had. The garlic knots were good too. We sat out on the porch with our dog which was..."

Courtney Cooley

"I had an amazing experience at Lillian's Pan Pizza! The pizza was out of this world – perfectly crispy crust, delicious sauce, and a generous..."

Joshua Lee

"Came out tonight to see the live music on Thursday nights, they have Rhonda Hart and Snokey Otis playing tonite. I was happy I came. We got two 10..."

K L

"I have seen this place but haven’t stopped until today. Lillian’s did not disappoint. Outstanding customer service, Fantastic food!!! A must stop..."

Rick Chesser

"Extremely enjoyed our pizzas. Took a little time, but it was all..."

David

"So my grandpa had passed away and we were in town for his memorial and all the family wanted to get together and have some pizza, so we came here...."

Factor - ade

"Best pizza within 45 miles of Orange Beach, Alabama! Every single year we look forward to coming here just for their stuffed pizza... basically 2..."

KC Holly Day

"A must stop for vacation. Ordered our food online and was ready in less than 15 minutes for pick up. My dad's name being Dave we of course had to get..."

Amber Frizzell

"Live music was great! Staff was super nice and attentive! Beer menu was decent. Mixed drinks were very good. Pizza was average at best. I will say..."

Scott Honeycutt

"Great pizza, lots of options for crust and toppings. We have visited the restaurant many times over the years as we take our annual month at the..."

Charles Jones

"Must stop place if you live here or just vacationing! Pizza dough is handmade and you tell tastes very good. 10/10 would come back! Our waitress was..."

Dayna Guinn

"This is the BEST PIZZA! We have visited the area for years and Lillian’s has never disappointed. We look so forward to this pizza! They are loaded..."

Kimberly Irwin

"Lillian's is a fun place to enjoy dining inside or out. They have a wide selection of beers and a full bar and a large and varied menu. We chose..."

Susanna Parkinson

"Great place for dinner. Happy hour is until 7 PM. All beer is bottled, no tap. Full bar. Sandwiches $5. Beer $2.12. (Nov. 2017) Pick up and delivery..."

Rob

"Updated for 2023: We're back and Lillian's still has the best pizza ever! We also have now experienced the best bushwhacker in Florida courtesy of..."

Lolly Chessie

"If you ever come to Perdido Beach, you have to stop here. Lillian pizza has the best pizza we have had tried from the PNW to here.. The shrimp..."

Reset

There are 8 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Alfredo in Pensacola

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Joji Yoshida

Esmeralda R.

Deborah Tracy

Pamela The Islandgirl

Rodney Davis

Angie Fei

Alexander Rios

Jonathan Welsh

Chef Donn Gueniot

Krysa Tash

Pam George-Tieman

JosRos Ros

Truth

Crystal Garcia

Brian McMahan

George Boyd

Prity Patel

Ingrid Rodgers

Bet Laycock Garcia

Angela Henrichs

Jessica Hatsfelt Everett

Ben Menefee

Erik Hansen

Kate Bergin

Sherry Sanford

Nicole Samuelian Ennis

Michelle Nelson-Schmidt

J&P PBandJ

Maksim Blair

Joshua Bollinger

Meagan Malloy

Polina Blair

Nilda Serrano

Raelina Wallace

Marilyn Evans

Katie-Ann

Kathryn Chesney

Sonny

Snoopy

Frances Guidry

Brandimichellemoore

Arnold Newton

Peridot

Tony

Susan

Lauren Alexandra Vassiliades

Gina Bonelli

Foodie Fan

Lindmaclaren

PatrMcGraw

Rebecca

Triggers Seafood Restaruant

Emily Martin

Jane Buttram

Helen Sewell

Salgal1710

Gourmet Mom

Cindy

Kay

Brittani

Citivolus Sus

A Better Food Snob

GourmetBaby

Roger Oak

The Pouty Princess

Kbolkeny

Rachel Cassady

Phillip Metcalfe