Lornadoone Gardner Myers
+5
The pizza was as good as it was when they were in University Mall. Our server was on top of her game. Our drinks were never empty and she also put our left over pizza in a doggy bag (pizza box) for us. The atmosphere was great and they had my fav beer, Yingling on draft.
My husband and I ate here for the first time this evening. I have to say that out of all the Italian places that we have eaten this is the best ! The pizza and Baked Ziti were amazing. True Italian flavor ! We will be coming back. Our waitress Ann was a blast too. Thanks for the great food and service!
Great food and great personal service. Their pizza is so deliciious. The sauce and cheese tasted so fresh. There was plenty of meat and cheese and the crust was exceptional. We will definitely be back to try their pasta dishes. If you want true italian food this is the place to go.
First time going and was treated very well. A little pricey if you're on a budget but it is worth it in the end. The pizza was amazing. Stuffed crust isn't stuffed to my liking, it was more like crust with a little bit of cheese in it. Would like to see actual STUFFED crust pizza.
Pensacola has some great pizza places but I have to say this is my FAVORITE!
Great calzone & the meatball appetizer is great!
NO JOKE. This pizza place. Wow. Called in a pick-up order, greek pizza chicago style with jalapenos added. Best pizza I've ever had in my LIFE. I will be back. Many times. So delicious.
Outstanding food. The lastvtime I had food this good was in the 90' in Italy. We go here often and make it a point to take visitors from out of town here. Although we live across the bridge in gulf breeze it is well worth the trip
First Visit. Me and my fiance' went here last night for the first time. It was recommended by a couple of people we knew and they were right to send us there. It was really good food. I had a calzone and he had the lasagna. It was late on a week day and it was really slow, but the service from the waitress was really nice. We had a nice dinner together.
Love it!. One of my favorite places for pizza or Italian. So good! The staff is also very friendly and welcoming. The interior is well-appointed and clean. The meatballs are the best meatballs I have had. And I am a meatball expert!
Better than it used to be. My wife and I grew up eating this pizza when they were still in University Mall 1976 to 80 something. After we heard the radio commercial that this was the same family we made dinner plans for Christmas Eve. Before going out looking at Christmas lights we drove from Milton to Pensacola to try they new restaurant. Our family of four ( 2 teenagers) order a couple of small pizzas, a calzone and baked ziti. The wait staff was polite and quick. The food....well the food was amazing!!! Better than I remember. Everything was fresh and hot. The dining room, tables and bathrooms were very clean.
Excellent experience, we WILL be back
The food was excellent! My family of 4 ordered a large meat pizza, small half n half, m 1 calzone. We were not able to finish it all! The atmosphere is clean and friendly. They were playing an awesome 80s/90s station too!
Nice quiet low key atmosphere. Good place for a date if you want to pay attention to each other. Pizza, salad and cheesecake were excellent. Prices are reasonable. Staff was friendly and efficient.
Best chicken parmesan I have had in years. Excellent chicken fettuccine alfredo, and Hawaiian calzone. Love the combo sampler platter as well as the Hawaiian pizza. We never had zucchini fries before. They are tasty. Superb service as well. A must visit place.
Great service and good food! The New York style pizza was delicious! Just the right amount of crunch to the dough and the right proportion of sauce and cheese. I didn't like the cheese in the jalapeño poppers but the pizza and service was well worth the visit!
This place is amazing! We came in looking for a Chicago style pizza, and man that it what we got! The dough was perfect. The cheese was real mozzarella and the sauce was fantastic. Three of us went out to eat and couldn't even eat half of the pizza. Looking forward to trying their New York style and Sicilian style pizzas. This will definitely become our regular pizza place.
I must admit I had my reservations about coming here. I remember when this place was another place and I was afraid they just slapped another name on the building. Not so. It was VERY good and since it's close to my house I'm afraid we'll be back many times. Can't wait to work my way through the menu.
5/22/2021 - First time here. Parking lot was full however plenty of seating inside. They also have a patio area. Nice decor. Service quick and friendly. Good fresh food.
I can't believe how good this place is! I first ran into this place as I was out shopping. I was hungry for pizza and had no real preference. Well, anything but the fast food pizza chains that I will not mention😉! I digress! The pizza I ordered was ready for pickup at the time given and it was hot! Take notes pizza restaurants! We actually like hot pizza! 🤣🤣! Again, I digress! The pizza was EVERYTHING! It was amazing! Here we are about a month later and i'm pizza hungry. Not expecting much or it to taste the same, I order another pizza. OMG! It was better than the last! This time one of the owners helped me (they are brothers). He was very accommodating, welcoming and professional at the same time. He made this veteran happy today! Please go try them out. Regardless of who you are, they will make you feel right at home! This place will see me as long as I live here! Thanks guys!
Italy's Finest is a local hidden gem located on 9th Ave. 3 minutes from Cordova Mall. Originally from Upstate New York, it's hard to find a good NY Style pizza. Fortunately this place reminds of LaRoma's Pizzeria back home in Rome, NY. A Family owned restaurant with young hard working servers. I ordered a 12 inch mega pepperoni (the name might be off). Ready within 15 mins. It only cost me $10.62 for this Delicious Goodness🤓🤗 The sauce is seasoned perfectly with great proportions on the pizza being built. Heavy cheese but not excessive, Mega pepperoni, & the crust is baked even. The crust has a light garlic & butter flavor. Great pizza! Italy's Finest does have a full bar & t.v. Next time I'll have to dine in. My reason for a 4 star rating is they don't offer wings. Needless to say I made my own wings at home. A New York Girl can't have pizza without hot wings, celery & blue cheese😂 Great Job Italy's Finest! Thank you for you bringing home to me.
Everything was super! We had combo appetizer, spaghetti carbonera and stromboli ... all great choices!
Awesome Italian. Great service. Full bar. Great specials. Clean. Great prices.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Pensacola
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes