I live in Palmyra and with six pizza shops here they have the BEST pizza hands down.My only complaint is they should due delivery, at times I am to lazy to go after my food.
I have been coming here since they opened in the 90’s! Always great food and service. 😀 Their Rolls and their sauce are the best. I have two pizza shops closer, but driving a little farther is worth it.
OMGoodness! This is the best eats by far in the area. I always go for the cold Turkey sub and the bread is out of this world. My son had the other half and agreed. A few days later we wanted another but got it from our local pizza shop where we live and there was NO COMPARISON!! Next time I will drive simply for the BEST!
Hands down the only place you should go for pizza, subs, stromboli, etc in the Hershey Palmyra area. This is a family owned business that offers exceptional customer service, homemade bread, and amazing food
Hands down, Bartolos has the best pizza I have ever eaten! Their cheesesteaks aren't bad either. I have been eating here since they opened in the early nineties. This is a pizza shop so don't expect anything too fancy, but they do have great food and great prices.
Just okay. The pizza sauce was a bit sweet for my taste and the amount of topping was a bit light. We did like the thick crust version. Not the best I have had but pretty good.
The best pizza around! The pizza sauce is excellent.
Great Cheesesteak. The pizza at Bartolo's Pizza is just OK, I prefer my pizza with a thinner crust. The pizza here has a thicker crust and is a little light on the cheese. I will say however, that the cheesesteak here is above average. The rolls appear to made on site and the meat and cheese is plentiful.
Consistency and Good Tasting Food. Today's world requires consistency in served food. Bartolo's Pizza serves up quality food in generous portions at reasonable rates. An always helpful and courteous staff provide quick to the counter service, seating is available for eat in or take out service. Time sensitive orders can be assured that being in business now for more then 17 years has proven a winner.
Parking is available in front of the store with more parking available past the curb on the south side.
Outdoor seating is available on their very small patio with one picnic table, this is usually made accessible for Team Sports celebration parties etc. Bartolo's Pizza proudly sponsors youth Team Sports on a regular basis!
I am a Regular Customer
Good pizza. What more do I need to say. The pizza here is good and not over priced so it works for me!!
The subs here are really good. The bread is great and if you’re a mayo lover, they put plenty on. The pizza is just alright. There is zero crisp or crunch, so if that’s you’re thing, keep looking.
We've been coming to this shop for 16 years, the past 8 years only when visiting the area. It's always a favorite stop! The pizza is a unique taste, and SO cheesy! We love it!
I've been coming to Bartolos since I was a kid! It's always the same guys. I'm assuming family owned. The food is spot on every time. Hot and delicious. The wait times hardly ever change, which from a buissness standpoint that's a good sign. In a nutshell, my almost weekly routine with this establishment adds comfort & enjoyment to my life! Thanks guys! I'm the young man who always orders the cheeseburger sub. No tomato, extra onion, add black olive. Side of corn fritters, and a sign of mushroom bites ❤
Prices are good, the food is great. Owner works the counter and is a nice guy. Love getting our pizza from here.
The hoagies are great on their fresh baked rolls. Pizza was very good. Quick freindly service.
I have been here a few times now and I will say that the pizza is fantastic. Cooked to perfection, delicious, and staff is great. A few tables inside and tables on the outside as well. Lots of parking and clean.
I have not had anything else to eat here yet , only the pizza. Can not comment on any other food items. But I definitely will be trying other stuff.
Been going here for a very long time... haven't seen them in awhile but am pleased to say.. they are still fantastic. Pizza
Great food ALWAYS. Nice family run pizza place. Friendly employees.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Palmyra
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes