Proccolino's Pizzeria

Pizza delivery guy tonight was deaf. He indicated that when I open the door. Handed me the receipt to sign for gratuity. Then thanked me for tip. I couldn’t understand the next statement he made. He tried twice but I wasn’t getting it. He took the time to write out the thanks for tip again and also “I hope you have a great weekend!” Then as he was walking out the porch door, he stopped to point out the sunset to me. Had such a big smile. Mostly gestures but I got it. Oddly,this was the highlight of my day - it was beautiful sunset which I would never have seen since I was holed up stressing about work stuff plotting my pizza comfort meal most of the evening. Made me little sad too though. Probably not an easy job for person who is hearing impaired. Credit to him for taking the time with interaction. I’ve ordered a lot of food delivery in the year. He’s oNe of the few to mention the gratuity (wish I had told him that) and was a lot of extra effort him.

Walked in here just to use the restroom. I thought it was just another bodega next to a liquor store. Walking in the door was like stepping through a portal into the heart of a Jersey-Rican's Italian dream. What a sensational find! An astonishing restaurant with an amazing atmosphere. Their walls are perfectly decorated with memoranda from our culture. The food was exquisite! Delectable taste to even their pizza slice. The service, superb. I'm absolutely enchanted. Cannot wait to spread the word. I'll be back with my friends. I highly recommend.

This is the only place I get pizza anymore! I moved into the neighborhood sometime last year and happened to try it out. I was expecting a nice local Italian place for takeout since it was right next to a bar. HOWEVER, I was not expecting such great staff, nice decor and fantastic quality and quantity on the food! I have since been here several times and have tried the wings to the eggplant parmesan and, of course, several different pizzas. It's all been great! Added a picture of a 18 inch chorizo pizza, enough eggplant parmesan for two, and so many garlic knots it doesn't fit in the takeout box taken from my cluttered kitchen table lol

I gotta support my Puerto Ricans 🇵🇷 I've been ordering from this place for 4 years. And the food always delivers. Love the wings and pizza and the oreo zeppoles are a must have. The garlic bread is also good. I have to tell you about one of the waiters, he's a bit on the spectrum so be patient, but he will listen for sure to your requests. Thank you for dealing with my mom who is a bit of a meticulous person. Oh yeah the cheesecake was cute.

Went alone for lunch on a Friday for my first time. No other customers when I walked in, so I was allowed to sit wherever I wanted. The Penne Rustica was very tasty and was enough of a portion to take some home. The bread that comes with pasta was delicious with or without the marinara of the pasta, and was enough to share with another. I ordered a pepperoni and sausage pizza and Zeppoles to go, and while they were brought out before my pasta, the server offered to keep them on the oven until I was ready to leave. I had a slice and one of the desserts later, and they were also delicious! I will definitely be back!

Hidden gem! The food is amazing and the service was awesome. Jonathan our server was super attentive and we felt like we never waited for anything. Appetizers came right out, salads next and then main course. Drinks always full. Portion size was on point and the price was very affordable. Definitely our new favorite place.

I love finding little gems. We eat out a lot and grow tired of chain restaurants. After reading comments we decided to try Proccolino’s. It’s a quaint restaurant with excellent service, lots of menu options and good food. Don’t be intimidated by the small parking lot, there’s extra parking behind the restaurant. We will definitely be back!